The glory years are what usually spring to mind when you bring up the history of the New York Yankees, whether the days of Ruth and Gehrig, the midcentury dominance of Mantle and Berra, or the 1990s dynasty. Those teams and players are honored time and time again for their contributions to their franchise. However, what’s not talked about as much are the lean years, such as the time prior to that dynastic run in the ’90s that set everything in motion for the future.

Those were some tough years for the organization, and while the team still had its fair share of big names (most notably, Don Mattingly) and wasn’t even finishing with records that were too bad, there were too many quiet Octobers in the Bronx. And for the first two years of his career, Brian Fisher was part of those ranks.

Advertisement

Brian Kevin Fisher
Born: March 18, 1962 (Honolulu, HI)
Yankees tenure: 1985-86

Born in Honolulu, Fisher and his family moved to Colorado, where he attended William C. Hinkley High School in Aurora and helped the school win a state title in 1979. After showing well in high school, he was selected by the Atlanta Braves in the second round of the 1980 MLB Draft.

Fisher worked his way up through the minor league ranks and developed a mid-90s fastball that could hit 97 mph, but before he could make it to the majors with Atlanta, he was traded. On December 5, 1984, Fisher was sent to the Yankees for catcher Rick Cerone, and he made his MLB debut on May 7, 1985, against the Minnesota Twins at the age of 23. He finished the day with three hits, no strikeouts, one walk, and one earned run in three innings pitched.

From there, Fisher went on to not just have a strong rookie season by comparison to others, but he had the best season of what would be an abbreviated professional baseball career. He finished the year with a 2.38 ERA and a 2.37 FIP, along with a 170 ERA+ and 2.4 bWAR in 98.1 innings pitched. Fisher was capable of filling whatever role skipper Billy Martin needed, whether it was covering middle innings, setting up for closer Dave Righetti, or even finishing off ballgames himself. Indeed, Fisher recorded 14 saves of his own, like the one in the clip below at Fenway Park, where he went four-up/four-down to both escape a jam and preserve a win for Ron Guidry.

Fisher also placed sixth in American League Rookie of the Year voting as the Yankees won 97 games but fell two wins shy of Toronto for the AL East crown.

Advertisement

Fisher would spend one more campaign with the Yankees organization. In 1986, he finished the year with a winning record at 9-5. However, over 62 games and 96.2 innings pitched, he posted a 4.92 ERA and a 4.45 FIP, with an ERA+ of 83 and a bWAR of -1.2, a harsh dropoff from his production as a rookie.

Over his two seasons with the Yankees, Fisher worked in the role of a starter and as a reliever, but after his second season in pinstripes, he ended up being traded for a second time in his career, this time to the Pittsburgh Pirates. It was a multi-player deal that included Brian Fisher, pitcher Logan Easley, and (most regrettably) pitcher Doug Drabek from the Yankees for another trio of pitchers: Rick Rhoden, Cecilio Guante, and Pat Clements.

Fisher moved into a starting role with the Pirates, pitching three seasons with the team from ages 25-27 and a total of 348.2 innings. He finished his Pirates career with a 4.72 ERA, inflated plenty by a poor performance in his final season (where he had a 7.92 ERA), albeit in limited innings after playing only nine games and starting three.

Fisher left the Pirates after three seasons and sign with the Houston Astros, where he pitched in only four games due in part to a broken knee that took a wrecking ball to his career. He did not play in 1991 and returned to the majors in 1992 at the age of 30, pitched 91.1 innings, and finished with a 4.53 ERA.

Advertisement

While it was not an incredible career overall for Fisher, he was able to pitch for a few storied organizations, and his rookie season in pinstripes was one he can certainly look back on fondly. Reflecting on it years later to the Denver Post, he knew just how special it was:

When I talk about pitching for the Yankees, it’s an icebreaker for any conversation … If I say that I pitched for the Pittsburgh Pirates, it doesn’t have the same impact.

For a brief moment, it looked as though the Yankees could have a prominent young arm on their hands to help bolster their staff into the late ’80s, but alas, Fisher can hang his hat on his rookie breakout.

See more of the “Yankees Birthday of the Day” series here.