The Detroit Tigers were supposed to build off their 2025 playoff appearance and take a legitimate step forward in 2026. Instead, they sit at a deflating 20-29 record, fourth in the AL Central and a full 7.5 games back of the Cleveland Guardians. The offense has been inconsistent, the rotation has been maddening, and the road record is an alarming 7-19. While the blame is shared across the roster, three names keep surfacing in Tigers fan circles as the biggest culprits behind this underperforming club.
Mike Watters-Imagn Images
Coming off a 2025 season in which he slugged 31 home runs with a .789 OPS and helped carry Detroit back to the postseason, Torkelson was expected to be the offensive engine of this lineup in 2026. He has been anything but. Through 48 games, he is slashing a woeful .194/.309/.381 with just seven home runs and 19 RBIs. His average has dropped nearly 50 points from last season, and his overall production has cratered at a time when the Tigers desperately need their first baseman to carry his weight at the plate.
The strikeout problem remains his Achilles heel. Earlier in the season, he was running a 28.6% strikeout rate, the kind of number that eats away at any batting average, regardless of how much raw power a hitter possesses. He did homer in five consecutive games in late April, briefly offering a flicker of hope that the breakout was coming, but the broader body of work this season tells a far more troubling story. FanGraphs projects him to finish the year with a .233 average, which would still represent a significant upgrade over where he stands right now.
Framber Valdez Has Not Lived Up to His Big Contract
Katie Stratman-Imagn Images
The Tigers spent heavily in free agency this winter to land Framber Valdez, a two-time All-Star who was supposed to anchor Detroit’s rotation for years to come. The early returns have been deeply underwhelming. Through 10 starts, Valdez owns a 4.58 ERA and a 1.40 WHIP, numbers that are a far cry from the dominant sinker-baller who helped Houston win a World Series and consistently posted sub-3.00 ERAs in his prime. His 2-3 record does not begin to tell the full story of how inconsistent he has been.
Valdez has always lived and died by his sinker, but the pitch has been far less effective in a Detroit uniform than it was in Houston. His ERA and WHIP rank him in the bottom half of AL starters by both metrics. For a Tigers team that is being outscored overall and desperately needs rotation stability, getting average production from their marquee free agent signing is simply not good enough.
Jack Flaherty Is Getting Paid $20 Million to Go 0-5
David Richard-Imagn Images
Perhaps no player on this roster is drawing more frustration from Tigers fans right now than Jack Flaherty. He exercised his $20 million player option to return to Detroit this past November, and through eight starts in 2026, he is 0-5 with a 5.77 ERA and a 1.60 WHIP. He has walked 29 batters in just 43.2 innings, and his strikeout-to-walk ratio of 48:29 is the portrait of a pitcher who cannot consistently command the strike zone. Those are not the numbers of a $20 million starter. Those are the numbers of a fifth starter on a rebuilding team, and right now that contrast is impossible for Tigers fans to ignore.
Flaherty showed real promise in Detroit during his 2024 tenure, going 7-5 with a 2.95 ERA over 18 starts and earning himself a two-year deal. But the 2026 version looks like a completely different pitcher. With the Tigers already sitting 7.5 games out of first place and the AL Central race tightening above them, the window for Flaherty to right the ship is growing smaller by the week. Detroit’s fans gave him the benefit of the doubt when he opted back in. That patience has officially run out.
The Detroit Tigers were supposed to build off their 2025 playoff appearance and take a legitimate step forward in 2026. Instead, they sit at a deflating 20-29 record, fourth in the AL Central and a full 7. 5 games back of the Cleveland Guardians. The offense has been inconsistent, the rotation has been maddening, and the road record is an alarming 7-19.