Having Alejandro Kirk and Tyler Heineman in the lineup in unison has demonstrated upside value for the Toronto Blue Jays. This was taken into action in their 9-1 victory over the Philadelphia Phillies on Thursday. Heineman, who started behind the plate, went 2-for-4 with three RBI and a run scored. Kirk, who was the designated hitter for the day, went 3-for-4 with an RBI and a run scored. It was a nice follow-up to his walk-off hit on Wednesday night.  Kirk is returning to his 2022 All-Star form and it’s been a huge boost that they have needed. Having both catchers in the lineup, with one DHing, helps maximize their offensive and defensive potential.

SORRY JORDAN ROMANO I LOVE YOU BUT ALEJANDRO KIRK JUST WALKED IT OFF ON YOUR HEADTOP!!!! pic.twitter.com/bHpJ9gLqd1

— ??Mr Bond (@ATKINSnCrewOut) June 5, 2025

Blue Jays Using Alejandro Kirk and Tyler Heineman in Lineup Working Out

Heineman, who hadn’t hit a home run since 2019 with the Miami Marlins, is also putting up career numbers. Kirk, who is the full-time catcher, provides the Blue Jays with a solid offensive presence and his obvious high-caliber defense behind the dish, particularly with his framing and blocking as well as his throwing arm.

Meanwhile, Heineman provides depth and versatility. The Blue Jays have received a surprising boost from the 33-year-old backstop, who made his mark early in the season providing value with both his offense and defense. He’s provided them with clutch at-bats, an effective means of throwing out base stealers, and he’s doing everything he can to get as much playing time as he’s owed. Heineman is also useful as a pinch-hitter or runner in games. But having Heinemann and Kirk in the lineup together is one of the best moves that manager John Schneider has made this season.

Kirk’s Offensive and Defensive Impact:

Alejandro Kirk is the team’s starting catcher, known for his strong offensive capabilities and defensive skills. Behind the plate, he improves the team’s ability to prevent stolen bases. 

Heineman as a Backup Option:

Tyler Heineman serves as a backup catcher, providing the team with a reliable option when Kirk needs a break or when the team needs a different offensive approach. 

Lineup Flexibility:

By including both players, the Blue Jays can strategically utilize Kirk’s strengths as a starting catcher and leverage Heineman’s versatility as a backup, potentially providing a competitive edge in certain matchups. 

While it’s unlikely that both players will be in the starting lineup every game, the Blue Jays could strategically use them together to address specific needs or matchups. For example, Heinemann could enter the game as a defensive replacement or to provide a different offensive approach depending on the situation.

Photo Credit: © Dan Hamilton-Imagn Images