With the second and final day of the MLB Draft concluded, here’s a quick recap of the major Mets news from Monday. This recap covers all the key moves and selections the Mets made from rounds 4 through 20.
Be sure to stay updated on every signing by following along with our 2025 Mets Draft Pick Signing Tracker. All names that feature a hyperlink will direct to our own Steve Sypa’s draft profile write up.
Round 4, No. 133: Peter Kussow, RHP, Arrowhead HS (WI)
The Mets grabbed 6’5” Wisconsin right-hander Peter Kussow, who’s been up to 97 with a sharp slider. He’s a Louisville commit and one of the more intriguing prep arms in the Midwest.
Round 5, No. 163: Peyton Prescott, RHP, Florida State University
The Mets added another big arm in Florida State right-hander Peyton Prescott, who was up to 100 MPH before needing Tommy John surgery this summer.
Round 6, No. 193: Nathan Hall, RHP, University of Central Missouri
Betting on upside, the Mets selected Division II right-hander Nathan Hall, a converted catcher with a fastball up to 98 and a promising slider. Hall had his 2025 season cut short by UCL surgery but showed enough raw stuff to intrigue teams.
Round 7, No. 223: Cam Tilly, RHP, Auburn University
The Mets’ sixth pick, right-handed pitcher Cam Tilly, boasts a mid-90s fastball with high spin and an above-average slider along with a curveball and splitter showing promise despite control issues.
The rest of the draft followed a familiar pattern for the Mets, prioritizing established college arms while mixing in a few high school prospects along the way:
Round 8, No. 253: Camden Lohman, RHP, Ft. Zumwalt North HS (MO)
Round 9, No. 283: Anthony Frobose, SS, Lakeland HS (NY)
Round 10, No. 313: Tyler McLoughlin, RHP, University of Georgia
Round 11, No. 343: Wyatt Vincent, OF, Nixa HS (MO)
Round 12, No. 373: Truman Pauley, RHP, Harvard University
Round 13, No. 403: Frank Camarillo, RHP, UC Santa Barbara
Round 14, No. 433: James Smith IV, RHP, University of Memphis
Round 15, No. 463: Conner Ware, LHP, Louisiana State University
Round 16, No. 493: Zack Mack, RHP, Loyola Marymount University
Round 17, No. 523: Sam Robertson, SS, Northwest Shoals Community College
Round 18, No. 553: Dillon Stiltner, RHP, Trinity Christian School (GA)
Round 19, No. 583: Joe Scarborough, RHP, Jacksonville State
Round 20, No. 613: Garrett Stratton, RHP, Rice University