The 2025 season did not get underway with the highest of hopes for fans of the Colorado Rockies, but things went even worse than could have been reasonably anticipated.
The team constantly struggles with pitching due to the ruthless back-and-forth of going from pitching at mile-high altitude to pitching in normal conditions, and that was the case again this year.
What normally serves as the wind in the sails of the team when it plays well is the fact that the Rockies typically produce a ton of offense in their hitter-friendly home environment.
In 2024, for example, Colorado finished a dreadful 61-101 overall, but went just seven games under .500 at home, 37-44. In 2025, the home record cratered to 25-56, leading to a disastrous 43-119 season overall.
Given the team’s struggles as a whole, it should come as no surprise that there were only a few individual standout seasons among the roster. Here are the five Rockies who produced the most wins above replacement according to Baseball Reference’s WAR tabulation.
1. Hunter Goodman, Catcher – 3.7 bWAR