Baseball is my first love, watching the Yankees win the 2009 World Series, watching Andy Pettitte and the guys take Mariano Rivera out of the game for the final time, chokes me up every time. I don’t know if there has been a holiday season where I wasn’t buying a New York Yankees gift, or receiving one. You truly can’t go wrong when shopping for gift ideas for their favorite team.
Whether you’re looking for something classic like a replica Yankees jersey or grabbing a good stocking stuffer with this Yankees hair clip for her, there’s something on this list for everyone. Here are the top categories to shop this holiday season for the Yankees fan in your life:
Shop the ultimate gift guide for New York Yankees fansPinstripes are iconic and make the best gift
The Yankees have one of the most iconic uniforms in all of sports, which makes it an even better gift for Yankees fans. The game day replicas do not have last names, but you can use those player jerseys as well. Lean into the current team, with Aaron Judge or Giancarlo Stanton, or go for history with Derek Jeter or Babe Ruth.
My dad’s been a Yankee fan since my grandparents were obsessed with Joe DiMaggio, and now we watch so much Yankees baseball that my five-year-old thinks we know Aaron Judge personally. Whether I’m shopping for my kiddo, my husband or my dad, these are some of the go-to gift options for him:
Knockaround Fan Shop Sunglasses are a year-round fan gear option
Knockaround Premiums Sport New York Yankees Sunglasses
Rock the Yankees year-round with these polarized sunglasses that come with a Yankees printed cover.
Comfort meets style with these internet favorite shoes from HeyDude
MLB Yankees Wally Funk
Slip into your favorite team with one of HeyDude’s most popular styles, featuring the iconic Yankees ‘NY.’
Keep all of your favorite drinks cold with a Yankees Yeti
Yeti x Yankees Collection
Shop premium coolers with the Yankee logo, or any of their ramblers, tumblers and flasks in a variety of sizes and colors.
Shop the Yeti x Yankees Collection
Invest in a premium Yankees wardrobe piece from Johnnie-O
New York Yankees Sully 1/4 Zip
This premium quarter-zip looks like it’s coming straight from the Yankees clubhouse.
Add Yankee stadium to their desk or home office
New York Yankees 3D StadiumViews Desktop Display
Let them daydream about stadium hot dogs and beer with this Yankee Stadium display.
I love a Yankees-themed gift. One of my favorites, a friend gifted me a DVD-copy of Derek Jeter’s 3,000th hit and last year a New York Yankees license plate was on my wish list. Amazon’s Fan Shop is a great place to start for great gift ideas that can also be budget-friendly.
But, there are also plenty of options if you’re looking for a gift that’s both stylish and sporty. This Yankees jean jacket is definitely on my list this year, while this Yankees hair clip and these NYY press-on nails both make for excellent stocking stuffer ideas.
Grab an accessory to keep her hair up while reppin’ her favorite Bronx Bombers
MLB Hair Clip
Don’t pull your hair out stressing over those close games, put it up with a Yankees hair clip.
This jean jacket is perfect for baseball season and layering up this winter
New York Yankees WEAR by Erin Andrews Women’s Full-Button Denim Jacket
This jean jacket is equally sporty and cute, but I also love the idea of adding stadium patches.
A great stocking stuffer idea: Yankees-themed press-on nails
New York Yankees Press-On Nail Set
Get your nails ready for your Yankee Stadium trip, Opening Day or a playoff series with this press-on nail set.
Every closet needs a Dooney & Burke purse
MLB Yankees Top Zip Crossbody
The strap is 26-inches with a zipper closure and one inside pocket.
A gift that sparkles: Shop Yankees jewelry at The GLD Shop
New York Yankees Official MLB Micro Logo Pendant
This Yankees pendant is plated in 18k gold.
Yankees tickets are always a welcomed gift
The 2025 MLB season is still underway, with the Yankees strolling into the American League Division Series after a dominant performance by rookie pitcher Cam Schlittler. So, as long as the Yankees stay in the postseason, tickets would make a great early holiday gift. Or, you can start planning for the 2026 season.
Get Yankees tickets now
Whether you’re aiming for the postseason, or planning ahead for the 2026 season, grab your Yankees toickets today.