The Cincinnati Reds have had a quiet MLB offseason to this point, making no major moves aside from re-signing closer Emilio Pagan to a two-year contract. The organization took a step forward in 2025 by returning to the postseason, a sign that their young core is beginning to mature into a legitimate contender in the National League. Although their playoff appearance was brief, the Reds showed enough promise to suggest they are on the verge of sustained competitiveness.
One looming concern, however, is the potential loss of outfielder Austin Hays, who played a key role in their success last season and is now a free agent. Hays joined Cincinnati on a one-year, $5 million deal last offseason and quickly proved to be a valuable addition. His production gave the Reds stability in the outfield and another reliable bat in the lineup.
Advertisement
According to Jon Heyman of the New York Post, the Reds may face competition if they hope to bring him back. Heyman reported Tuesday that the New York Mets have discussed Hays internally and view him as a potential fit.
“Mets have discussed Austin Hays internally and have some interest. Had very nice year in Cincy (.768 OPS). The righty hitting OF is among potential fits,” Heyman noted.
That interest is understandable. Hays posted a .266 batting average, a .315 on-base percentage, a .768 OPS, 15 home runs and 64 RBIs in 2025, delivering consistent offense throughout the season.
Advertisement
His ability to hit left-handed pitching, provide defensive versatility and slot into multiple lineup spots made him one of Cincinnati’s most dependable contributors. Hays also has a strong track record across eight seasons in the league, even earning an All-Star selection with the Baltimore Orioles in 2023. For a Reds team that is still shaping its roster around a young core, losing Hays would create a significant void.
The Mets’ involvement raises the stakes for Cincinnati. New York is looking to bolster its outfield depth after falling short in 2025, and Hays’ combination of experience and steady production makes him an attractive option. For the Reds, the priority should be clear: they cannot afford to let one of last season’s most reliable players walk away.
If Cincinnati wants to build on its progress from 2025, retaining Hays is essential. His presence not only strengthens the lineup but also provides veteran stability for a team still learning how to win consistently. The Reds have shown patience this offseason, but when it comes to Hays, urgency is required.