New York Yankees starting pitcher Carlos Rodon (55) pitches against the Toronto Blue Jays (Image via Imagn) The New York Yankees are being linked to Bo Bichette as trade discussions around the league pick up. The idea gaining traction involves sending Jazz Chisholm Jr. to the Toronto Blue Jays, a move that would directly affect both teams inside the division.For the Yankees, the interest is about stability at the plate. The lineup has power, but it has also been streaky. Bichette offers steady production and contact. Toronto, meanwhile, would be moving a core player but gaining flexibility, athleticism, and possible future assets.
How the Deal Could Take Shape
The framework centers on Chisholm heading to Toronto in exchange for Bo Bichette. Chisholm is under team control through 2026, which adds value for the Blue Jays. Bichette is entering the final year of his contract at $16.5 million, making him easier to move without long-term payroll concerns. 
Toronto Blue Jays Shortstop Bo Bichette (Image via Getty)
To balance the trade, Toronto could also receive players such as Ernie Clement, Joey Loperfido, or pitching prospect Ricky Tiedemann. In New York Yankees, Bo Bichette would likely move to second base, allowing Anthony Volpe to stay at shortstop. The Yankees would then be in position to pursue a long-term extension with Bichette, likely in the $150–230 million range over five to seven years.
Why the New York Yankees Are Interested in Bo Bichette
Bo Bichette’s value is simple: he hits. In 2025, he batted .311 and led the league with 181 hits. He gives the New York Yankees a reliable bat near the top of the order and reduces pressure on the middle of the lineup when runs are hard to come by.Defense is part of the discussion, as Bichette has graded below average at shortstop. Playing second base would limit that concern and keep his bat in the lineup every day.
What Toronto Gets Back
Chisholm brings power, speed, and flexibility. He hit 31 home runs, stole 22 bases, and can move around the infield. Pairing him with Vladimir Guerrero Jr. would give Toronto a different offensive look. Added prospects would help soften the loss of a consistent hitter.
Key 2025 Stats Comparison
PlayerTeamGAVGHRRBIOPSWAR (est.) Bo Bichette TOR 139 .311 18 94 .852 4.2 Jazz Chisholm Jr. NYY 130 .242 31 80 .813 3.5 Anthony Volpe NYY 152 .245 12 62 .712 2.8Also read: MLB trade rumors: Los Angeles Dodgers explore $10.15 million Detroit Tigers star’s trade as title window stays wide openWho Benefits Most?New York gets the more dependable hitter and avoids the risk of losing Chisholm in free agency. Toronto gains athletic upside and depth but gives up its most consistent bat. If this deal happens, it would favor the Yankees in the short term while pushing the Blue Jays toward a different roster balance.