Callis has great expectations for Hernandez and thinks that he’ll not over get over the century-mark in innings pitched, but show exactly why the Pirates took him as high as they did.
“I think Hernandez had the highest ceiling in last year’s Draft,” Callis wrote. “The stuff is unbelievable. The control is advanced. I think he’s going to pitch around 100 innings and be pretty spectacular.”
What the Pirates Get in Seth Hernandez
Hernandez stands 6-foot-4, 190 pounds, commanding an imposing presence on the mound. He als throws four pitches, a fastball, a curveball and a changeup, his three best pitches, while also throwing a slider.
His draft stock rose quite quickly, as he was homeschooled his first two years of high school, before pitching for Corona.
He finished with a 9-0 record, a 0.62 ERA over 56 innings pitched and 73 strikeouts as a junior in 2024, while also batting .350, with eight home runs and a 1.080 OPS.
Hernandez dominated in his senior season in 2025, striking out 105 batters over 53.2 innings pitched, averaging almost two strikeouts per inning, while also posting a 0.39 ERA. He earned 2025 Gatorade National Baseball Player of the Year honors at the high school level for his performance.
MLB Pipeline has scouting grades for Hernandez at 70 for his fastball, 60 for his curveball, 55 for his Slider, 60 for his changeup, 55 for his control and 55 overall.
His fastball is his best pitch, reaching around 100 mph, but the break he gets on his curveball is impressive and he has good control over his changeup.
Hernandez, while not officially pitching for the Pirates, did pitch down at Pirate City in Bradenton, Fla., where he should start next season with the Florida Complex League (FCL) Pirates.
He also pitched in the Dominican Republic for the Pirates academy in the country, located in the municipality of El Toro.