Gavin Williams (Image Source: Getty) As the Cleveland Guardians extended Gavin Williams’ 2025 contract, the young pitcher has found success over his first two years in Major League Baseball, but like many of the Guardians’ youth players, has garnered interest from fans and experts during this time.With Gavin Williams’ impending arbitration eligibility looming and there being interest in extending Gavin Williams’ current contract before he becomes eligible for arbitration, many believe the Guardians are contemplating extending his contract. Most recently, the Guardians have indicated they will continue to focus on locking up young talent, but will face difficulty doing so with Gavin Williams’ current representation.
Gavin Cleveland Guardians consider extending Gavin Williams amid ace potential
According to reports, the Cleveland Guardians are currently in conversation about signing pitcher Gavin Williams long-term, a move that matches their trend of signing other young, talented players (e.g., Jose Ramirez’s recent $175M deal). However, with Gavin represented by Scott Boras, whose clients usually go to free agency and receive higher payouts than extension agreements, there doesn’t seem to be a real chance for Gavin to sign this extension.Nonetheless, due to Gavin’s impressive 2025 numbers (12-5; 3.06 ERA), the Guardians will likely continue negotiations, given that his arbitration dates start in 2027, mitigating their potential for cost increases later on.
Salary outlook points to growth for Williams in coming years
Williams’ estimated salary for the 2026 season will be approximately $820,000 based on pre-arbitration guidelines after he received an estimated amount of $780,000 from 2025’s salary. According to projections, he may have a 3.59 earned run average over 29 games pitched this season, which would improve his potential to receive arbitration awards when he becomes eligible for arbitration next year at the end of this season. His estimated net worth before playing this season stands at approximately $2.6 million based on total career earnings to date.As a result, if he can produce solid numbers this season, it is possible that he could receive more than $5 million in annual arbitration awards next season based on the numbers given by comparable pitchers who are going through similar transition periods between positions.