Vinnie Pasquantino (Image source: Instagram) The Kansas City Royals have resolved their first big arbitration case of the winter by agreeing to a two-year, incentive contract to first baseman Vinnie Pasquantino, averting a hearing scheduled next month. According to Anne Rogers of MLB.com, the deal is guaranteed for over $11 million and could increase to nearly $16 million in performance bonuses, although the exact breakdown year by year is yet to be released.Moreover, Pasquantino had just become arbitration-eligible for the first time going into the 2026 season. MLB Trade Rumors contributor Matt Swartz, projected Pasquantino’s salary to be around $5.4 million, but the two sides remained apart at the filing deadline earlier this month, with Pasquantino putting in a $4.5 million figure and the Royals countering at $4 million. Rather than enter into a process that has the potential for a contentious battle, the two parties chose a multi-year pact, one that locks in cost certainty, preserving goodwill.
Multi-year deal helps the Royals avoid hearing
Across Major League Baseball, most clubs now have a “file and trial” policy, cutting off negotiations on one-year contracts once arbitration figures are turned in. The system has been designed to avoid extreme filings and to preserve leverage as either the number of a player or team is to be selected by the arbiter rather than to be split down the middle. While arbitration is widely regarded as business as usual, things can sometimes go awry in relationships – as demonstrated in Corbin Burnes case after his hearing with the Milwaukee Brewers three years ago. By reaching an agreement that lasted two years, Pasquantino and Kansas City were able to avert the possibility of that happening while paying for the first two of his three arbitration seasons. The slugger is still scheduled for arbitration eligibility yet again in 2028, before hitting free agency.
League-wide impact and Royals’ remaining case
The deal also limits the total number of arbitration hearings around the league this winter to a maximum of 14. Of the 18 players that had remained unsigned at the deadline, Cade Cavalli, Bryce Miller, Joe Ryan, and now Pasquantino have all made deals in recent days. However, Kansas City is not completely free from the risk of arbitration. The Royals have one outstanding case of left-hander Kris Bubic, who was slated for a $6 million deal. Bubic’s filing was at $6.15 million compared to the club’s $5.15 million number, leaving the door open for a hearing unless a compromise is reached in the coming weeks.For now, the Pasquantino deal provides the Royals with stability at first base and eliminates one notable offseason distraction as they head into the 2026 season.