Boston Red Sox’s Jarren Duran (Image via Getty) The idea of the Boston Red Sox trading Jarren Duran and Brayan Bello for Detroit Tigers left-hander Tarik Skubal is only a mock scenario. Nothing has been formally discussed, but the concept has drawn attention because it shows where both teams stand. Boston is still looking for a clear No. 1 starter, while Detroit must decide what to do with a top pitcher who is getting closer to free agency.The situation also reflects the cost of acquiring an elite arm. Skubal has won the Cy Young Award twice and remains under team control through the 2026 season, which raises his trade value. For Boston, a move like this would signal a push to win now. For Detroit, it would be about turning one major asset into several long-term pieces rather than risking his departure without a return.
What the trade could look like
Most mock trade versions have Boston sending Jarren Duran, Brayan Bello, and at least one additional premium asset – usually a top-10 prospect or a high draft pick – to Detroit for Tarik Skubal.Boston Red Sox receive: • LHP Tarik Skubal (29 in 2026, arbitration-eligible, coming off a second straight Cy Young season).Tigers receive (mock scenario): • OF Jarren Duran (29, everyday outfielder). • RHP Brayan Bello (26, mid-rotation starter). • At least one top-10 Red Sox prospect or a high draft pick.Boston would be trading for one elite season and hoping it leads to a championship run in 2026. Detroit would be moving a walk-year ace while his value is high.
Why Boston Red Sox would consider the move for Tarik Skubal
Boston Red Sox have added pitchers such as Ranger Suárez and veterans Sonny Gray and Johan Oviedo, but the rotation still lacks a clear frontline starter. Tarik Skubal would immediately fill that role.His recent numbers explain why he is in demand: • 2025 AL Cy Young winner • 13-6 record with a 2.21 ERA • 241 strikeouts • 0.89 WHIP in 195.1 innings • Led the American League in ERA and WHIP • 2.30 ERA with a 31-10 record across the last two seasonsPutting Skubal at the top of the rotation alongside Garrett Crochet would give Boston a strong one-two combination, the type that often matters in the postseason. Boston also has outfield depth with players like Wilyer Abreu and Alex Verdugo, which could make Duran easier to move if the return is an ace.
Why Detroit might listen to offers
Boston Red pitcher Jose De Leon (78) is relieved as they take on the Detroit Tigers in the seventh inning (Image via Imagn)
Detroit Tigers have to weigh Tarik Skubal’s timeline. He is under contract through 2026 and is represented by Scott Boras, which usually points to a large free-agent deal.Trading him now would allow the Tigers to: • Avoid losing him without compensation • Add players ready for everyday roles • Bring in prospect depth • Keep roster flexibility during a retoolJarren Duran would give Detroit a dependable outfielder with speed and defensive range. Brayan Bello would provide a controllable starter who could settle into the middle of the rotation.Duran also fits a lineup built around younger hitters like Riley Greene and Spencer Torkelson, while Bello could slot behind pitchers such as Casey Mize and Jack Flaherty.
Skubal vs. Duran vs. Bello – statistical comparison
Skubal’s recent dominance (2024-2025)
SeasonW-LERAIPKWHIPNotes 2024 18-4 2.39 ~200 228 0.92 AL Cy Young, Triple Crown-type season. 2025 13-6 2.21 195.1 241 0.89 AL Cy Young, led AL in ERA and WHIP.Over those two seasons, Skubal has a 31-10 record, a 2.30 ERA, and roughly 470 strikeouts.
Jarren Duran (2025 season)
Metric2025 ValueNotes AVG .256 Solid but not elite contact. HR 16 Power-speed profile. RBI 84 Table-setter and middle-of-order bat. OPS .774 Above-league-average offensive contributor. Runs / SB 100+ runs, ~20 SB Elite baserunner and table-setter.Duran projects as a leadoff or No. 2 hitter with defensive value and consistent power.
Brayan Bello (2025 season)
Metric2025 ValueNotes W-L 11-9 Mid-rotation starter. ERA 3.35 Solid but not elite. IP 166.2 Workhorse starter. K 124 Moderate swing-and-miss. WHIP 1.24 Generally efficient.Bello profiles as a No. 3 or No. 4 starter with room to improve.
Boston Red Sox’s side: benefits and concerns
Benefits • Adds a true ace to a rotation that already includes Suárez, Crochet, Gray, and Oviedo. • Strengthens the top of the staff for a potential playoff run. • Uses depth at other positions to address a clear need.Concerns • Skubal could leave after one season. • The trade cost would be significant. • Moving Bello and a top prospect would reduce pitching depth.
Detroit Tigers’ side: benefits and concerns
Benefits • Turns a possible free-agent loss into multiple assets. • Adds players who can contribute right away. • Improves organizational depth for future moves.Concerns • The team would lose its top pitcher. • Fans may react negatively to trading a homegrown ace. • The rotation would be weaker even with Bello added.Also read: MLB trade rumors: Chicago Cubs potentially eyeing $22.025 million Arizona Diamondbacks Cy Young candidate in his free agency
Who comes out ahead?
Detroit likely benefits more in the long run if Skubal leaves after 2026. Getting Duran, Bello, and a premium prospect for one year of an ace would reshape the roster. Boston’s outcome depends on winning. If Skubal helps deliver a championship, the cost becomes easier to justify. The scenario highlights a common decision in baseball. One team pushes for a title now. The other looks toward sustained success.