As much as we would like to believe otherwise sometimes, baseball teams have no crystal balls. Sometimes things happen out of the prescribed order, gambles don’t pay off, or players who you just brought in may almost instantly become redundant.
The latter might be what happened to Carl Edwards Jr.
Not that when Edwards was signed to a minor league deal, he was promised a spot on the major league roster. But he seems like a player who David Stearns and co. had a specific vision for, and that vision might be a better fit for another player now.
A three-pitch pitcher who relies on his four-seamer and curveball for the bulk of his work, the right-hander, when going right, gets soft contact and ground balls off the bat. Edwards has an over-the-top arm angle with a large extension, resulting in a lot of spin on his fastball.
Edwards was drafted by the Rangers in 2011 and was traded to the Cubs as part of the Matt Garza deal in 2013. After many accolades in Chicago’s minor league system, he made his MLB debut as a reliever in September of 2015, but was called up for good in June and was a part of the Cub’s World Series run.
From there, Edwards compiled a journeyman’s career out of the bullpen. He stuck in the majors for most of the 2010s with the Cubs before being traded to the Padres in 2019 where he had as disastrous of a two-game stint as you can imagine, putting up a six earned runs in an inning and two-thirds of work. He signed with Seattle before the 2020 season, but appeared in just five games in the COVID-shortened season.
2021 was another lost year, bouncing around the Atlanta, Toronto, and White Sox organizations, making a handful of big league appearances. In 2022, Edwards found some success with the Nationals, appearing in 57 games with a 3.19 ERA. This led to a $2.25 million contract with Washington for 2023, but shoulder injuries limited him to just 32 appearances.
A total of five big league appearances between three teams over 2024 and 2025 only tell part of Edwards’s most recent story, however. Outside of the MLB games, Edwards has been starting more than relieving since 2024, starting nine games for the El Paso Chihuahuas in the Padres system, eight games across the Angels and Rangers systems in 2025, and 14 for the Tigres de Quintana Roo in the Mexican League this past offseason. And while he hasn’t turned into Sandy Koufax on the hill, it hasn’t been all bad. He’s put up an ERA in the high fours and, based on Will Sammon and Ken Rosenthal’s reporting, this may be what attracted the Mets to Edwards.
With plans to stretch him out into a starter, the Mets might’ve been looking at Edwards as a swingman who could give them some bulk innings out of the bullpen and a spot start here and there. That seemed like the most likely path for Edwards to make the club until Tobias Myers came over from the Brewers in the Freddy Peralta trade. Myers is a more established version of what the Mets hoped Edwards could be and seems likely to have that role for the 2026 team.
Where does that leave Edwards? It’s unclear, but teams make these sort of signings all the time with the knowledge and, perhaps, expectation that they won’t work out. That’s cold comfort to the players themselves, but if Edwards has a good spring, there are plenty of teams looking for essentially the same role. Thus is the life of a journeyman pitcher.
Post-script: As a society, we don’t use his nickname of “the String Bean Slinger” nearly enough. Let’s make it happen.