Today’s question: Which trade, in Jays history, still bothers you the most? Well, the question was supposed to be “Is this team actually trying to contend or are they just pretending?“ but I didn’t think that would give us much to talk about.

This is an easy one for me, the trade that still pisses me off the most was from 1996, 30 years ago. You’d think I’d be over it by now. But no. In 1996, Gord Ash (actually, the top 10 Jays trades that bother me the most are likely all Gord Ash trades). This one though…this one almost had me questioning whether I wanted to be a baseball fan anymore.

Advertisement

Gord Ash traded John Olerud to the Mets for some Person (Robert Person). Olerud was my favourite. He was 27, just coming into his prime. He was a lefty hitter, I was a lefty hitter (and that’s where the resemblance ended). But he was a spray hitter, walked a lot, and could hit the occasional home run. Kind of the type of player I would have liked to have been, had I any talent at all.

I was looking forward to watching his career.

And we traded him for a pitcher who didn’t strike out all that many hitters, walked far more than any pitcher should. Person went 8-13 with a 6.18 in 61 games 22 starts, in 2 and a bit seasons. A -1.7 bWAR.

We traded him to the Phillies for Paul Spoljaric, who, in his second go around with the Jays wasn’t much better than Person.

Advertisement

Olerud? Well, in three seasons with the Mets, had a 17.3 bWAR and a .315/.425/.501 line with 63 home runs. He had the best run of his career. From there, he went to the Mariners, where he had a 17.1 over four and a half seasons.

The kicker to it all, was that we traded Olerud to make from for an aging Joe Carter to play first. Carter would hit .234/.284/.399 with 18 home runs in the season after the trade and left as a free agent.

Now why did they trade Olerud to keep Carter? Well, Cito Gaston liked Carter and he didn’t like Olerud. And Ash was a young GM, new to the job. Gaston was a World Series winning manager.

I’ve said this before, but a strong GM would have told Gaston that Olerud was a young star, and that we need to keep him. Barring that, a good GM would have traded the young star for, you know, a valuable baseball player. A poor GM would trade Olerud for Robert Person.

Now it is your turn.