The Phillies opened their 2026 spring training by officially moving away from veteran slugger Nick Castellanos, ending a four-year run in Philadelphia. For a lot of fans, it felt like the shoe finally dropped. Because once the team barred him from spring training, the writing was on the wall!
Still, letting go of Castellanos seems tougher for a few across the Phillies. And why not?
Advertisement
Castellanos’ time with the Phillies was about more than home runs. Remember, he immediately rushed to Orion Kerkering after a season-ending mistake in Game 4 of the NLDS. It’s something even Phillies infielder Otto Kemp’s family knows well. Even at the top of the organization, the emotions are real.
His departure closes a chapter that was messy at times, but undeniably meaningful to a lot of people inside and outside the clubhouse.
“Not many people know this, but right when Otto was moved up, Nick offered us a place to stay in their home… Jess and Nick treated us like family… Thank you for guiding Otto and giving us a home away from home…” These are the parts of a heartbreaking message shared by Kemp’s wife via Instagram and reshared by Nick Castellanos wife, Jess.
MLB, Baseball Herren, USA Philadelphia Phillies at New York Yankees Jul 27, 2025 Bronx, New York, USA Philadelphia Phillies outfielder Nick Castellanos 8 celebrates with catcher J.T. Realmuto 10 after hitting a solo home run against the New York Yankees during the second inning at Yankee Stadium. Bronx Yankee Stadium New York USA, EDITORIAL USE ONLY PUBLICATIONxINxGERxSUIxAUTxONLY Copyright: xJohnxJonesx 20250727_jhp_ja1_0082
So, for fans who’ve mostly seen Castellanos through the lens of the very public fallout with Rob Thomson, this might come as a surprise. But the truth is, he is more than what we’ve seen over the past few months.
Advertisement
Take Otto Kemp’s story, for example. When Kemp first broke into the majors, he had to make the move from California to Philadelphia. During that transition, Castellanos opened his home to him. That kind of gesture says a lot, and it’s something Kemp’s family hasn’t forgotten, especially now that Castellanos is leaving Philly himself.
However, two things can be true at once. Castellanos bringing alcohol to the dugout just as a symbolic protest against his manager is surely not following MLB’s rulebook. Despite his altercation with Thompson over a fielding snub, opening a beer in the dugout, and in full public view, is condemnable. So, the reported “Beer Gate scandal” is absolutely something that can’t be brushed aside.
It’s serious, and it played a role in how all of this unfolded.
Still, the way it ended caught a lot of people off guard, including Dave Dombrowski. “Things happen, things change over 15 years, I’ve still had a good relationship with Nick and his family members, I’ve known them all. But it doesn’t always happen, so that’s just the way life is, not only here, but life in general. I’ve known him for a long time. He’s been a very good player; he’s had a nice career. He’s done a lot of good things, and he probably will continue to do so… You always wish that things end up on a good note, a la Ranger Suarez when he’s leaving and he’s pitching very well, but it doesn’t always happen.”
Advertisement
For Dombrowski, this one hits especially close to home. He drafted Castellanos back in 2010 and was there for his development and his MLB debut in 2013. So, watching that full-circle journey end this way is emotional, even if it was unavoidable.
So yes, it’s a promising stint that ends on a sour note. And now the question is simple: which team will be the one to unlock the best version of Nick Castellanos next?
Castellanos still has some gas left in his tank for another winning season
Nick Castellanos is 33 now and coming off a rough 2025 season, with plenty of controversy mixed in. But all that noise shouldn’t make anyone forget what he’s still capable of! Before he was benched in 2025, Castellanos had started 236 straight games. And at one point, he even went 414 consecutive games without making an error.
Advertisement
So, that kind of durability and reliability is wild by any standard, let alone today’s MLB.
Now, to be fair, defense has been a problem. Castellanos finished last among all outfielders in OAA at minus-12, which put him at the bottom of the league defensively. He knows it, too. That’s why he’s reportedly open to learning first base if it helps him land with a new team and extend his career.
Hereon, all it takes is one good stretch for things to change. And maybe this split from the Phillies ends up being exactly what Castellanos needs. A fresh start, a new role, and a clean slate might just be the first step toward a real bounce-back season.