The MLB season is underway, and teams are already pushing to exceed their 2026 expectations. However, some clubs still can’t seem to put everything together.
On Thursday, the Pittsburgh Pirates scored seven runs but delivered an embarrassing defensive performance. The outing unraveled so badly that the team pulled its starting pitcher before he could even finish the first inning.
MORE: Paul Skenes a New York Yankee? The blockbuster MLB trade that almost was
Now, the Pirates have made a tough and surprising decision ahead of Saturday’s Game 2 against the New York Mets. Reports indicate they have benched slugger Oneil Cruz.
It remains unclear whether this move will last, but Cruz has been one of the Pirates’ most dangerous offensive weapons. The decision is puzzling, especially since the team has remained committed to playing him in center field—a position he is still learning.
Cruz previously thrived as a shortstop. Last season, the Pirates moved him to center field midyear to address a glaring roster need.
MORE: Former Cubs World Series champion retires from MLB at 36
The experiment has not gone well, and instead of making the logical adjustment, the Pirates continue to mishandle the situation. They should move Cruz back to his natural position.
Pittsburgh Pirates center fielder Oneil Cruz (15) tries to throw the ball into the infield before the Mets could score in the first inning, Thursday, March 26, 2026.
This benching may prove temporary, and Cruz could still bounce back. However, with little development at his new position, the Pirates risk wasting both his time and his talent.
This situation is not entirely surprising. The Pirates have struggled as an organization, and they now risk mismanaging their generational pitching talent in Paul Skenes.
Winning can fix many issues, but the current signs point in the wrong direction. The Pirates need to return to basics—starting with moving Cruz back to shortstop.
— Enjoy free coverage of the top news & trending stories on The Big Lead —
MARCH MADNESS: 2026 Sweet 16 TV schedule, game times & dates for NCAA Tournament
MLB: Predicting the winner of every MLB game on Friday, March 27, 2026
NFL: NFL pushes back Tom Brady’s sensational return to football
SPORTS MEDIA: Sweet 16 announcer pairings & TV schedule for 2026 NCAA Tournament
ENTERTAINMENT: 2026 iHeartRadio Music Awards winners, Taylor Swift leads full list
VIRAL: Taylor Swift, Travis Kelce tower over 5-foot-3 Olympic champ Alysa Liu