The general opinion of NBA fans and media is that Michael Jordan is the greatest shooting guard of all time and Magic Johnson is the greatest point guard of all time. The truth is that both were the best in their craft in terms of what their positions demanded on the floor.
As for MJ, no one has ever dominated offensively like him, which is confirmed by his 10 scoring titles, with Wilt Chamberlain next in line with “only” seven. The general belief is that in one-on-one, he was unstoppable. When Magic was once asked if he could beat his 1992 Dream Team teammate, Magic gave an intriguing answer.
Advertisement
“Michael would win. That’s not my game. My game is assisting, setting up my teammates. Michael’s the greatest one-on-one player. I couldn’t go out and drop 60 like him, but he couldn’t run a team like I could” Johnson singled out.
Both had a full package in their game
Magic led the league in assists four times, which isn’t close to the all-time leader John Stockton’s nine, but back in the day, he was truly revolutionary, considering his size and the way he played the game.
Advertisement
There had never been a player with Magic’s frame who influenced the game so much purely through his basketball IQ and court vision. But that doesn’t mean he couldn’t score when it was required.
Just remember his rookie season when, in Game 6 of the NBA Finals, he delivered a championship to the Los Angeles Lakers by stepping in at the center position after Kareem Abdul-Jabbar was injured. He dropped 42 points, grabbed 15 boards, and dished seven assists along with three steals.
Although his career high was 46 points, he always played on teams with proven scorers where he wasn’t asked to be the primary scoring option, even though he showed multiple times that he could do it.
Advertisement
A similar case was with Jordan. After the Chicago Bulls asked him to take on playmaking duties, he delivered with 10 triple-doubles in 11 games, proving he had a full package in his game and could also lock in on facilitating when needed.
The impact on the game was different
That was one of the best all-around seasons in league history, as MJ finished the regular season playing 81 games with averages of 32.5 points, 8.0 rebounds, 8.0 assists and 2.9 steals on 53.8 percent from the field.
Advertisement
On the other hand, Magic had the best season of his career in 1986-87, finishing with averages of 23.9 points, 12.2 assists, 6.3 rebounds and 1.7 steals on 52.2 percent from the field across 80 games.
However, when Magic was asked if he was competing with MJ for the greatest of all-time title, the Lakers legend knew the pecking order.
“We haven’t seen anybody do the things that Michael could do,” said Magic. “He was physically so gifted, at the same time, smart.”
Advertisement
Nonetheless, both legends could do absolutely everything on the court, as their skill sets were off the charts. But it was also an era where every player knew exactly what their position demanded. Michael terrorized opposing defenses with his scoring, while Magic’s impact on the game was completely different, but equally dominant.
This story was originally reported by Basketball Network on Sep 17, 2025, where it first appeared in the Off The Court section. Add Basketball Network as a Preferred Source by clicking here.