Targeting NCAAB player props is one of the best ways to profit from the college basketball season. Picking the best player prop bets daily is challenging, but our team of basketball experts is always on the hunt for profitable opportunities.
Expect daily predictions from us, as long as the season is active. Here are our best NCAA college basketball player props today, December 23!
Best College Basketball Player Props Today, December 23 (Overview)
You can find the reasoning for our recommended college basketball player prop bets in the next section!
Best NCAAB Player Prop Bets Today, December 23 (With Reasoning)
Let’s explore the reasoning behind our best college basketball props today, December 23:
Total Points: Duke Brennan (VILL) Over 10.5 (-135)
Duke Brennan’s scoring prop is well worth a look as Villanova takes on Seton Hall Tuesday night. Listed at over 10.5 points (-135), this number feels short considering how efficient and consistent the 6’10” senior has been lately.
Brennan is averaging 12.2 points per game on a blistering 63.6% shooting clip, but it’s his recent stretch that jumps off the page. He’s scored 13 or more in four of his last five games, looking confident and assertive in Villanova’s frontcourt. His ability to finish at the rim has been elite, connecting on at least 70% of his shots in each of his last three starts.
DEFENSE ➡️ OFFENSE
DUKE BRENNAN BOTH WAYS pic.twitter.com/Zvbs9IHI9d
— Villanova Enthusiast 😺 (@NovaKnowsBall) December 7, 2025
Seton Hall doesn’t have the size or discipline inside to consistently disrupt Brennan’s rhythm. He’s thriving in the paint, and with his form trending upward, this over looks like one of the sharper prop angles on the board tonight.
Total Points: Elijah Fisher (SHU) Over 9.5 (-120)
Seton Hall’s Elijah Fisher is a strong target for the over 9.5 points (-120) prop in Tuesday’s Seton Hall vs. Villanova matchup. The sophomore wing has quietly become a steady contributor for the Pirates and enters this game in one of his better scoring stretches of the season.
Fisher is averaging 9.3 points on 46% shooting this year, but recent form tips the scale in his favor. He’s posted 16, 10, and 10 points in his last three outings and has hit double figures in five of seven games since November 24. That consistency is key, especially against a disciplined Villanova squad where every scoring option matters.
Elijah finds the range out of the locker room 💪 pic.twitter.com/Tlpm9gSUbK
— Seton Hall Men’s Basketball (@SetonHallMBB) December 20, 2025
If Seton Hall is going to pull off the win, Fisher will need to stay active offensively. With momentum on his side and his role growing, the over 9.5 prop has clear value in a game that should demand his best.
Best Bookie for NCAAB Player Prop Bets
Our favorite online bookie for college basketball player props is Bovada. The site offers loads of markets for all big games, excellent odds, and various cool promotions.
For a start, new players can grab Bovada’s welcome bonus worth up to $1,000 with a promo code BV1000. The extra cash can be used to bet on college basket player props.
Ready to play at Bovada
Welcome Bonus
50% up to $250
Wide-ranging sportsbook and live betting platform
Top-notch poker room with numerous tournaments