The Cleveland Cavaliers entered this season expecting answers to confirm last season’s rise to the top of the standings. After years of patient roster building and playoff experience, this was supposed to be the season where continuity paid off. Instead, they are finding themselves confronted with harder questions. As of now, Cleveland sits at 21-17 and sixth in the Eastern Conference, a position that reflects competitiveness without clarity. With the NBA trade deadline set for February 6, 2025, the Cavaliers are approaching a defining stretch where every win, loss, and rotation choice carries long-term implications for the franchise.
Donovan Mitchell Delivers and Raises the Stakes
On the floor, Donovan Mitchell remains Cleveland’s safety net. He is the closer, the tone-setter, and the reason the Cavaliers can survive offensive droughts. His scoring and late-game presence keep this group competitive on a nightly basis.
The standings, however, throw his importance into sharper focus. Mitchell’s timeline looms over every front-office decision. Cleveland does not have to trade its All-Star guard, but the closer the deadline gets, the more pressure builds to determine whether this core can realistically make a deep postseason run. If the answer is uncertain, Mitchell becomes the league’s most powerful leverage piece, not because the Cavs want to move on, but because standing still carries its own risk.
Garland and the Fit Question That Lingers
Darius Garland’s season has been defined by flashes of brilliance mixed with frustrating stretches. At his best, he is decisive and creative. When he drifts, the offense slows and spacing tightens. The issue is not talent. It is alignment.
Two ball-dominant guards can coexist in today’s NBA, but only when responsibilities are clearly defined. As February 6 approaches, Cleveland must decide whether this pairing has reached its ceiling or if a roster adjustment could better balance the offense and reduce the late-game burden on Mitchell.
The Atlanta Hawks attempted this type of two-guard approach with Trae Young and Dejounte Murray. Fast forward to 2026, and Murray has since been traded, and Young is reportedly on the block. Trae Young, however, brought the Hawks to at least one conference finals. The Cavaliers have not reached that deep into the postseason since future Hall-of-Fame player LeBron James donned the jersey.
Mobley, Allen, and a Defense Being Tested
Defensively, Cleveland still leans heavily on Evan Mobley and Jarrett Allen to control the paint. Their presence keeps the Cavaliers competitive on that end, but the league has adjusted. Stretch lineups and physical wings continue to test Cleveland’s interior-focused approach, forcing tougher rotations and exposing inconsistent perimeter defense.
Mobley’s development remains central to the franchise’s long-term vision. His defensive impact is undeniable, and his offensive confidence continues to grow. The question is whether internal growth alone is enough or if the trade deadline calls for adding a reliable two-way wing who can stabilize lineups when playoff matchups tighten.
Why the Trade Deadline Matters More Than the Record
Cleveland’s current record and sixth-seed position do not doom the season. What matters more is how this roster responds when games slow down and matchups are exploited. Too often, late possessions lean toward predictable isolation scoring, and certain opponents continue to expose limitations that will not disappear in a seven-game series.
That is why the February 6 trade deadline feels unavoidable. Cleveland does not need a blockbuster to remain relevant, but it does need clarity. Whether that means consolidating depth, adding shooting, or redefining the backcourt hierarchy, the front office must decide if patience still serves the franchise’s long-term goals.
A Season About Direction, Not Panic
The Cavaliers are not broken. They are unfinished. This season has revealed a team good enough to compete and disciplined enough to stay relevant, yet still searching for the defining edge that separates contenders from strong regular-season teams.
The trade deadline will not decide everything, but it may decide direction. For a franchise that has spent years building toward sustained success, choosing inaction could prove to be the boldest gamble of all.
Photo Credit for featured cover image: Getty Images.
Follow me on Twitter (now called X) for NBA news and articles. Like and subscribe to my new basketball podcast, The Hardwood Huddle. Please also follow Belly Up Sports for the latest sports content.