Coach Jim Penders and UConn’s baseball team returned from the Big East tournament to face a sleepless night and a little intestinal discomfort.

“We’ll have a little agita, for sure,” Penders said Sunday, as he rode the bus back to campus.

The Huskies, who lost to Creighton, 7-4, in the tournament final on Saturday, will have to hope that the intestinal fortitude they showed through the second half of the season is enough to convince the NCAA selection committee to include them in the field of 64, to be revealed at noon on Monday.

“We had one of the best second halves in the country,” Penders said. “I feel full in a lot of ways that our guys represented our program and our heritage very well with our fight after having dug such a big hole early in the season. To compete the way we did down the stretch was awesome.”

Dom Amore: UConn baseball rides out storms, ready to attack Big East, NCAA tournaments

UConn (38-21) is on the dreaded bubble as the committee sorts out 29 automatic qualifiers and the dozens of contenders for 35 at-large bids. That is now beyond UConn’s ability to control. The Huskies were 13-17 in April, and lost their first two conference series to Creighton and Xavier, then won 15 conference games in a row and 25 of their last 29 games. But there is more to being selected than just finishing strong.

“We feel as though our resume speaks for itself,” Penders said, “we’re not going to go politicking or tweeting or begging for a bid. We’ll let the entirety of the season will speak for itself and merits pretty well. That being said, the committee has a hard job to do and we’re going to be right on that edge.”

Fairfield can watch the Selection Show with its bid secure, after freshman Nolan Colby blasted a 10th-inning home run to lift the Stags to a 7-6 victory over Rider to clinch the MAAC championship on Sunday in Pomona, N.Y. The Stags (39-17) controlled the tournament with wins over Sacred Heart and Rider, then after Rider rallied to tie the game Sunday, prevailed. Ridgefield’s Matthew Bucciero drive in two runs, to become the program’s career RBI leader, and TJ Schmalze also homered as Fairfield reached the NCAA Tournament for the third time.

Central Connecticut was playing LIU in a winner-take-all match later Sunday for the NEC tournament championship.

It is not considered likely that the NCAA will take three Big East teams, as the conference is ranked 12th in strength metrics and had only the top three teams in the top 100 RPI. Two “bid steals,” or upsets in conference tournaments Saturday, in which Texas-San Antonio won the AAC’s automatic bid and Western Kentucky took Conference USA’s, have made the bubble even smaller. It could make Creighton the Big East’s only entry in the Field of 64.

If it comes down to UConn, 40th in RPI, or Xavier, 39th, for one of the last spots, it will be a razor’s edge choice. In their latest bracket projections, Baseball America and D1baseball.com both have UConn among its last four in, Xavier among its first four out.

Dom Amore’s Sunday Read: CT native a must-see for U.S. soccer team; UConn reload and more

UConn (19-6) has better overall and conference records, but Xavier (32-27, 15-9) beat UConn three of five in head-to-head play. UConn was 3-6 vs. the top two teams in the conference, but did eliminate Xavier in the conference tournament on Friday. UConn has a several out-of-conference wins that could play well with the committee, such as two in three games at Miami, and single wins over North Carolina, seventh in RPI and the ACC champion, and Vanderbilt, which is No.1 and won the SEC title, and beat several other eventual conference champs. But the Huskies’ non conference strength of schedule is ranked 48th, Xavier’s fourth. UConn’s national reputation and recent history of strong performances in the tournament, reaching the Super Regional round in 2022 and 24, is an intangible that could influence a subjective choice.
The Huskies will be keeping tabs on other conference tournament finals for clues, and then gather on campus and watch the Selection Show.

“We’ve been there six straight times and we know what an NCAA-caliber team looks like and we feel as if we have one,” Penders said. “But it’s up to other folks. It’s just a frustrating feeling when you’re a competitor and you’re no longer competing, you’re wishing and hoping for another opportunity to compete. “

Originally Published: May 25, 2025 at 6:22 PM EDT