The 2026 Rookie of the Year conversation felt almost settled even before it began when the Dallas Mavericks selected Cooper Flagg as the first overall pick in the 2025 NBA Draft. Touted as one of the “most complete” prospects the league has seen in years, Flagg entered the season as a -225 betting favorite before playing a single professional minute. At that point, nobody probably imagined that his former Duke roommate, Kon Knueppel, the fourth overall pick by the Charlotte Hornets, might emerge as a serious challenger. Eight months later, that unlikely possibility is ruling the ROTY conversations.
On Steve Aschburner’s latest NBA Rookie Ladder, published on March 4th, Knueppel sits right at the top, just ahead of Flagg. After they faced each other for the first time in a pre-season game in October last year, Flagg said about Knueppel, “That is somebody who is going to be a friend of mine for life.” It is this bond between the two top contenders that makes the race one of the most interesting in recent memory.
Duke Duel For 2026 NBA ROTY: Cooper Flagg Vs Kon Knueppel
Cooper Flagg’s Promising Start Faced The Injury Roadblock As Kon Knueppel Surged Ahead
The Mavericks handed Flagg the keys to an offense in rebuild mode. He responded, albeit after some initial hiccups. Flagg’s games continued to become more polished as the season progressed. He currently leads all the rookies in points per game with 20.3. The highlight of his rookie career came on Jan. 29, in a head-to-head matchup against Knueppel’s Hornets. Flagg dropped 49 points, the most ever scored by a teenager in NBA history. That prompted Knueppel to call him “the best player on the floor tonight.”
However, Flagg’s momentum stalled after a left midfoot sprain kept him sidelined since Feb. 10. Knueppel did not let the opportunity slip. He continued logging in historic numbers during that span. The impact was telling. Knueppel overtook Flagg in Aschburner’s last rookie ladder of February. Although Flagg returned to the court on March 5th, he might have to battle hard to reclaim the ground he lost, because, as the NBA coaches often say, “one of the best abilities is availability.” If we take a closer look at the numbers of the two rookies, an intriguing fact unfolds.
Flagg And Knueppel’s Season Stats
Flagg is averaging 20.3 points, 6.5 rebounds, 4.2 assists, and 1.2 steals per game across 51 contests. Knueppel, on the other hand, is logging 19.3 points, 5.4 rebounds, and 3.4 assists. Apparently, the Mavericks’ rookie leads in every category. But from an efficiency standpoint, Knueppel is mind-blowing. He is shooting 44% from the 3-point line, which is seventh best in the league. Flagg is connecting 29.4% from deep. If that is not astonishing enough, Knueppel is leading the league in 3-pointers made this season with 222. To add to that, he has also broken the NBA rookie record for threes in a single season, with 18 games still to go.
Knueppel’s shooting efficiency has him on the periphery of the rare 50-40-90 club, a feat that puts his name alongside legends like Steve Nash, Larry Bird, Kevin Durant, and Stephen Curry. For a fourth overall pick in his first professional season, that is an extraordinary benchmark. Flagg has 19 games to turn the tide in his favor.
Feb 26, 2026; Indianapolis, Indiana, USA; Charlotte Hornets guard Kon Knueppel (7) shoots the ball in the first half against the Indiana Pacers at Gainbridge Fieldhouse. Mandatory Credit: Trevor Ruszkowski-Imagn Images
Who Has The Edge Between Flagg And Knueppel At This Point?
Both rookies are posting historic numbers, but their circumstances are very different. ESPN analyst Kenny Smith has sided with Flagg precisely for this. “I probably have to give the slight edge to Flagg because he has more responsibility,” Smith argued. “He not only has to score the basketball, but he has to defend, and he has to rebound and play-make. Knueppel is having an unbelievable rookie season, but his job is to score the basketball, and that’s it. But he’s doing it at a high level. But Cooper just has more responsibility for me.”
Indeed, with Kyrie Irving injured and Anthony Davis traded to Washington, Flagg has been the Mavericks’ offensive engine, primary playmaker, and defensive anchor. Knueppel operates in a more defined role. Hornets coach Charles Lee, unsurprisingly, sees it differently. “I don’t even think it’s close,” Lee said bluntly, making no secret of where he stands on the debate.
One factor that significantly affects voters’ choices is the team’s performance. Hornets are 16-4 in their last 20 games. With a 32-32 record, they are pushing for a play-in spot, the franchise’s first since the 2015-16 season. Dallas, meanwhile, sits at 21-42 and is firmly in lottery territory. Knueppel has been central to the Hornets’ turnaround. He has helped transform a team widely seen as a laughingstock into a legitimately competitive group.
The counterargument is that winning games and winning Rookie of the Year are different ballgames. Flagg carries a heavier load precisely because Dallas is rebuilding around him. His usage rate, his defensive assignments, and his playmaking burden simply would not exist in Charlotte.
Flagg and Knueppel Battle It Out In The Last Leg
Before his injury, Flagg had scored 27 or more points in five of his last six games, shooting 46.2% from three during that stretch. His development in pick-and-roll situations alone has been striking: early in the season, he was attacking with little nuance; now he reads defenses, manipulates coverage, and makes the right decision under pressure. Such growth is difficult to quantify, but impossible to miss. Knueppel, meanwhile, shows no signs of cooling. His screening, spacing, and shot-making continue to create problems that defenses have yet to solve.
Mavericks head coach Jason Kidd, who shared the 1995 Rookie of the Year award with Grant Hill, probably had the most balanced response to sum up the state of the race: “I think when you talk about Coop and Knueppel, they play the game the right way. Cooper and Knueppel are heads of the class. It’s going to be interesting to see who wins Rookie of the Year.”
Kidd’s comments make it feel like the race is still wide open. In roughly six weeks, the ROTY voters will seal the fates of the two rookies. At this critical juncture, both teams hit the road on Sunday, March 8th: Flagg against the Toronto Raptors and Knueppel against the Phoenix Suns. They have entered that phase of the race where every game will take them closer or farther away from the coveted award.
Featured Image: