The Orlando Magic have gone all-in and entered win-now mode following their blockbuster trade with the Memphis Grizzlies.
In exchange for Kentavious Caldwell-Pope, Cole Anthony, and potentially five first-round draft picks, the Orlando Magic acquired Desmond Bane.
It’s safe to say that the trade took many by surprise, but the signs were already there. For instance, the Memphis Grizzlies GM’s end-of-season comments hinted at this move.
But coming to the Magic’s reasoning behind making the move, former NBA star Gilbert Arenas blatantly labeled the trade ‘dumb.’
Photo by Justin Ford/Getty ImagesGilbert Arenas berates ‘dumb’ Orlando Magic for trying to enter win-now mode with Desmond Bane
For what it’s worth, Bane is coming off a season averaging 19.2 points, 6.1 rebounds, and 5.3 assists per game for the Grizzlies.
On paper, it makes sense to add a talented scorer like him to the roster, but Arenas is simply not convinced by the price that the Magic paid to trade for Bane.
“They’re not fleeced, they’re just dumb. It’s literally the Orlando Magic. There are some teams out there that don’t care about their future. Dynasties [are] built off decisions like this,” Arenas said on Gil’s Arena.
“The trade is fine, it’s the picks, unprotected, you got to have at least top three. If you get to the number one or two picks because something happens to your team, you just lose it.
“But they don’t really care about building right now. Win now, but they [are] not good enough to win now,” he added.
Did the Orlando Magic overpay for Desmond Bane?
The Magic finished as the seventh seed in the Eastern Conference with a 41-41 record in the 2024-25 NBA season. Coming into the playoffs, they were sent home in five games by the Boston Celtics in the opening round.
But the thing is that the East is likely to be wide open next season, with Jayson Tatum likely missing major time due to his injury and the Celtics reportedly looking to blow up their core.
The likes of the Philadelphia 76ers, Cleveland Cavaliers, and New York Knicks remain as inconsistent as ever. If all goes well, the Milwaukee Bucks and Indiana Pacers could prove to be an obstacle in the Magic’s path to reaching the NBA Finals.
So, making a win-now mode trade was indeed the correct choice to make. However, was giving up four unprotected draft picks a wise decision?
The Magic have the likes of Paolo Banchero, Franz Wagner, and Jalen Suggs, who are all yet to hit the prime of their careers.
Now, adding a talented star who can drop 20 points on any given night will likely make the franchise a championship contender for the majority of the next decade.
Eventually, that would mean that the Magic would stay out of the lottery and the picks that they gave up would likely land somewhere between the 20th to 30th spot in the NBA Draft. So, yes, the Magic may have taken a gamble, but it’s a calculated one.