The career of Kansas City Chiefs left tackle Josh Simmons has evolved into an uncomfortable word that no one wants to hear: a “saga.” Simmons’ tantalizing talents on the football field keep him firmly in the long-term plans on the offensive line, but numerous obstacles—some known, some unknown—have kept the 23-year-old out of the lineup for all but eight games since the beginning of his career.
A very brief rundown of Simmons’ career begins with question marks surrounding the patellar injury sustained at the end of his college career at Ohio State. Despite the injury, Simmons’ immense potential kept him on the Chiefs’ draft board, and he was ultimately selected 32nd overall. Simmons recovered from his knee injury extremely well and started the first five games of his career. Just before Week 6, he began a mysterious four-week hiatus, one that still has not been explained publicly. After the Chiefs’ bye week, Simmons returned to the lineup for the team’s Week 11 game and started the next three games before suffering a season-ending wrist dislocation and fracture on Thanksgiving Day against the Dallas Cowboys.
Simmons returned after offseason training looking svelte and began training camp without a hitch. Unfortunately, he suffered a lower back injury at the end of camp and has not been seen in uniform since. Simmons remained on the 53-man roster for the first five weeks of the 2026 season, but it was determined he had “plateaued” in his progress, so the team placed Simmons on injured reserve on October 22.
The Chiefs have not had an immediate sense of urgency to rush Simmons into their lineup because his backup, Kahlil Benson, has performed serviceably in his stead. The rookie UDFA from Indiana has exceeded every expectation in his first season in the NFL. But a healthy Josh Simmons is still this team’s best option at left tackle, so when can Chiefs fans expect to see him back on the field?
Andy Reid offers little clarity on Simmons’ return
No one—not even Andy Reid—really knows the answer to that question at this juncture. During his Monday presser, Reid would only indicate that he had not yet visited with team trainer Rick Burkholder about an update on Simmons. At a glance, that is a discouraging outlook, but Reid did not explain any further.
Now that Simmons’ minimum four-week stint is over, the team can decide to open a 21-day practice window in which he can return to practice in some capacity while being designated to return from IR. After 21 days, the team must activate him or leave him on IR for the remainder of the season, including the playoffs.
Without knowing Simmons’ injury timetable, the only thing the Chiefs can map out is how much to play him once he’s ready to suit up.
The Chiefs face a difficult decision with Simmons’ playing time
Even in a best-case scenario, should the Chiefs open the window this week, there is serious doubt about whether even a healthy Simmons should play a full game on Sunday when the Chiefs host the Cardinals. The reason is twofold: One, the Chiefs have a short week next week, as they play on Thanksgiving night. A four-day turnaround might be too much to ask for a 310-pound offensive lineman coming off a back injury.
The second reason is that the Thanksgiving game is against Buffalo, one of the top contenders in the conference. That game is shaping up to have major implications for AFC postseason seeding, so even if Simmons is healthy enough to play this week, the Chiefs may want to preserve him for Buffalo instead.
That said, would you prefer to throw him in cold turkey on Thanksgiving night in upstate New York? The forecast for that game appears to be brisk, around 40 degrees at kickoff. One could make a case that it would help to get Simmons’ feet wet against the Cardinals, with 5–10 snaps under his belt.
A challenging schedule complicates Simmons’ comeback
If the window is not opened this week, the schedule does not get easier for Simmons’ return. After they go to Buffalo, the Chiefs will travel out west to face Myles Garrett and the Los Angeles Rams, again on Thursday night. After that game, the Chiefs will have ten days’ rest before they travel to Cincinnati to face the Bengals.
Of course, no one knows if or when “healthy Josh Simmons” will ever be back in uniform. Unfortunately, his story as a professional athlete has been more of a mystery than an action novel. The good news is that the end of that story is still untold, and Simmons’ potential (though yet untapped) is still sky-high.
Add us as a preferred source on GoogleFollow