MIAMI GARDENS — Thanks for joining us for the 2026 Miami Dolphins Q&A, where we’ll answer reader/viewer questions each week from Dolphins Deep Dive w/Perk, which airs at noon every Tuesday on YouTube.

Q: Does anyone have Christian Wilkins’ agent number? — @malbcrazy

Wilkins, the 30-year-old defensive tackle who was the Dolphins’ 2019 first-round pick, hasn’t played in the NFL in more than a season due mostly to a foot injury sustained in 2024 while he was with Las Vegas. The Dolphins have an injury-shortened defensive tackle rotation due to recent season-ending injuries to Zach Sieler (biceps), Zeek Biggers (right knee) and Jordan Phillips (right biceps). Yes, the Dolphins could use a run-stopper such as Wilkins. But it ain’t happening for a few reasons. Wilkins’ age, health, and fit for the rebuild are all deterrents.

Miami enters Sunday’s game at Buffalo facing the prospect of stopping running back James Cook (971 yards, No. 2 in NFL) with few proven run stoppers at defensive tackle. Kenneth Grant and newly-signed Keith Cooper Jr. will lead the tackle rotation for a defense that allowed a season-worst 172 yards rushing last Sunday against Indianapolis and has allowed at 100 or more yards rushing in six consecutive games. This is a crisis situation.

Q: Mestemaker or bust. — @markcoleman

OK, let’s do the NFL draft talk. Oklahoma State quarterback Drew Mestemaker (6 foot 3, 215 pounds), an athletic type, is a man of mystery because, including high school, he’s spent one-plus season as a starter. The Dolphins opening training camp in 2027 with a quarterback lineup of Malik Willis, Mestemaker and Kyle McCord would be, well, interesting from where we sit right now.

Mestemaker, in 10 games this season he has 30 touchdowns, which leads the nation, and 10 interceptions to go along with 3,239 yards passing, which also leads the nation. He’s completed 66.4% of his passes. OSU has a 6-4 record, including an early-season win over then-No. 6 Oregon (39-31).

Mestemaker was a backup quarterback and punter at Austin (Texas) Vandergift High School and attended North Texas as a walk-on quarterback in 2024. After serving as a backup as a freshman he won the starting job in 2025 and passed for 4,379 yards, 34 touchdowns and nine interceptions. In 2026, he followed coach Eric Morris to Oklahoma State.

I’m unsure if general manager Jon-Eric Sullivan and coach Jeff Hafley would draft such an inexperienced quarterback as their starter, and I’m unsure Willis would be a better option.

Q: There is no QB worthy of a high first-round pick this year so try to grab Jeremiah which is the closest thing to a sure thing in the first round. — @evanlangleyMa​​

Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith, who attended Chaminade-Madonna High locally, is the best prospect in the draft. He’s better-regarded than any of the top quarterbacks including Mestemaker, Notre Dame’s C.J. Carr, Miami’s Darian Mensah, Texas’ Arch Manning, Ole Miss’ Trinidad Chambliss, Oregon’s Dante Moore or South Carolina’s LaNorris Sellers.

Smith is big (6-4, 222), strong and fast with great hands and great stats (80 receptions, 1,317 yards, 15 touchdowns).

My thing is the Dolphins just had a future Hall of Fame wide receiver in Tyreek Hill and they didn’t go anywhere. And that was after matching Hill with an above average quarterback (Tua Tagovailoa) and a good fellow wide receiver (Jaylen Waddle) in a pass-happy offensive system.

I still favor drafting an edge rusher in the first round or perhaps trading down.

Q: Colin Simmons is a beast. He was unblockable against LSU. — @ericbedenbaugh

Texas edge rusher Colin Simmons is a beast. I agree. South Carolina edge rusher Dylan Stewart is also a beast. Right now, either would be good for the Dolphins. Put either alongside veteran edge rushers Chop Robinson and Josh Uche and the Dolphins might be on the verge of a game-changing pass-rushing rotation.

Dolphins Deep Dive: What did we learned about McCord in his debut? | VIDEO

Q: Sup Perk who are we drafting if Mensah is on the board??? LETS GO HEAT — @cdola

Good question. Mensah would be a popular pick considering he’s a University of Miami quarterback. But his performance without star wide receiver Malachi Toney should be watched closely.

As for other draft options for the Dolphins, perhaps Notre Dame cornerback Leonard Moore is in the discussion. Put him opposite Dolphins rookie cornerback Chris Johnson and in a crew that includes Jason Marshall Jr. and JuJu Brents, and you have a talented set of cornerbacks that have depth as well as Pro Bowl potential.

But the reality is it’s way too early to say which direction the Dolphins will go in the first round. They have lots of needs, and half of a season to see which positions are good and which are lacking.

Dolphins Deep Dive: Defensive tackle dilemma as injuries mount | VIDEO

Q: Dolphins are 17-point underdogs vs the Bills!!! This season can’t end soon enough. — @IGOTGAMEAJ ​​

Actually, I see them as 16.5-point underdogs in a few places, but let’s not split hairs. Remember that this is a developmental season for the young, rebuilding Dolphins. The final score and/or margin won’t be as important as how the injury-depleted Dolphins play. So far this season they’ve proven to be a physical team that plays hard and doesn’t quit. That’s what you want to see Sunday and every other game, and it’s pretty much what we’ve seen.

Dolphins Deep Dive: Who will Miami be looking to draft? | VIDEO

Q: ​​I’m a bit tired of coaches doing the Riverboat Gambler routine. Needlessly going for it on 4th and 2 eventually came back to bite them in the ass. — @MyUnclejay 

I liked that decision in the 24-22 loss at Indianapolis. Tight end Greg Dulcich was open in the end zone in the second quarter with the score tied at 7-7, and the pass from McCord might have been caught for a touchdown except Colts defensive tackle Grover Stewart deflected the ball a bit.

It was a good call and poor execution, the latter being a phrase that might have arisen on a field goal attempt.

Dolphins Deep Dive: Does Miami stand a chance against Buffalo? | VIDEO

Q: How do you feel the rookie class is performing? Above or below expectations? — @dlazar

The rookie class, both the draft class and the undrafted free agents, is performing very well. I’d say they’re definitely above expectations. You know the top draftees, led by left guard Kadyn Proctor and Johnson, the first-round picks, and linebacker Jacob Rodriguez, the second-round pick, have been really good. Wide receiver Caleb Douglas, one of three third-round picks, and safety Michael Taaffe, the fifth-round pick who leads the team with three interceptions, have also been good.

And when you consider undrafted rookies such as fullback D.J. Herman and edge rusher Rodney McGraw, and recently-acquired running back Kaytron Allen, a sixth-round pick by Washington who was claimed off waivers, it’s been a highly-productive rookie class.