Kansas City’s backfield enters a transitional phase as Kareem Hunt and Isiah Pacheco prepare for potential role changes. Hunt has thrived as the featured option during Pacheco’s absence, but that workload concentration faces imminent challenges. Can fantasy football managers trust either Chiefs runner this week against the Indianapolis Colts?
Check out the FREE Start/Sit Optimizer from PFSN to ensure you are making the right decisions for your fantasy lineup every week!
Kareem Hunt’s Fantasy Outlook
Hunt has operated as the unquestioned lead back over the past two games, claiming a 79% snap share that eliminated the committee approach entirely. Despite reports suggesting Brashard Smith would split carries, no such timeshare materialized. Hunt has delivered at least 12.5 fantasy points in three consecutive contests, providing the consistency that defines a viable RB2.
The touchdown production has been particularly impressive. Hunt has found the end zone in three straight games, showcasing his value in scoring situations. This red-zone prowess represents his most valuable skill set, as he continues dominating opportunities near the goal line while also handling passing-down work.
MORE: Free Fantasy Football Start/Sit Optimizer
Hunt’s recent performances haven’t been matchup-winning, but they’ve offered a reliable floor for managers navigating bye weeks and injuries. The veteran back has maximized his opportunity during Pacheco’s absence, demonstrating he remains a capable feature runner despite his age. His combination of volume and scoring chances has made him a solid weekly starter.
The key question moving forward centers on workload sustainability. Hunt’s elevated snap percentage reflected Pacheco’s unavailability rather than a permanent role change. With Pacheco returning to practice after his MCL sprain, Hunt’s near-exclusive access to backfield touches faces significant reduction.
Isiah Pacheco’s Fantasy Outlook
Pacheco returns to action following a two-game absence due to his MCL sprain suffered in Week 8. The injury sidelined him for what became three weeks when factoring in Kansas City’s bye. He participated fully in practice as the Chiefs began Week 12 preparations, signaling his expected return to game action.
Whether Pacheco immediately reclaims starting duties remains uncertain. His performance this season hasn’t justified automatic reinsertion as the primary ball carrier. Regardless, the designation of “starter” carries minimal meaning in Kansas City’s backfield, as both runners will see significant playing time regardless of who takes the first snap.
READ MORE: Soppe’s Week 12 Fantasy Football Start ‘Em Sit ‘Em: Analysis for Every Player in Every Game
Pacheco has averaged a 55% snap share this season, establishing himself as more of a 1a option than a true feature back. That workload distribution predated his injury and likely represents the ceiling for his involvement moving forward. The more pressing concern involves his scoring opportunities disappearing entirely.
Hunt will retain both the goal-line role and passing-down responsibilities, severely limiting Pacheco’s fantasy upside. Without access to short-yardage situations or receiving work, Pacheco lacks clear paths to fantasy production. His rushing efficiency between the 20s hasn’t been strong enough to compensate for these limitations, making him an unappealing option even in his first game back.
Should You Start Hunt or Pacheco This Week?
Indianapolis presents a challenging matchup, allowing the 13th-fewest schedule-adjusted fantasy points per game allowed to running backs. The Colts function as a pass-funnel defense, ranking bottom-five in schedule-adjusted fantasy points allowed to wide receivers and tight ends. This defensive structure should encourage Patrick Mahomes to attack through the air rather than lean on his ground game.
The game environment projects favorably for Kansas City. The Chiefs opened as 3.5-point favorites with the total sitting at 50.5 points, suggesting a competitive contest. However, Indianapolis’s defensive tendencies make them more vulnerable through the passing game, which could limit overall rushing attempts for both Chiefs backs.
Hunt faces inevitable snap-share reduction with Pacheco’s return. The 80% workload concentration disappears immediately, with projections suggesting a closer 50-50 split moving forward. This dramatic decrease in volume relegates Hunt to touchdown-dependent RB3 status, as his weekly floor collapses without guaranteed touches.
Fantasy managers should bench Pacheco in his first game back. He offers no clear path to fantasy scoring without goal-line carries or receiving opportunities. Hunt remains marginally startable as an RB3 due to his touchdown upside and passing-game involvement, but expectations should be tempered significantly. Neither back deserves confidence in lineups this week unless depth issues force the decision.