During the Buffalo Bills‘ loss in Week 12 to the Houston Texans, Josh Allen was struggling to find any help on offense.
Khalil Shakir delivered his best performance of the year, which helped keep them in the game, but once again, Allen was left without enough playmakers. That led to one of his worst stat lines of the season, with the reigning NFL MVP going 24-of-34 for 253 yards with no touchdowns and two interceptions. Worst of all, Allen was sacked eight times in the loss.
MORE: Bills considering unemployed former first-round pick as potential pass rush insurance
One player who would have made a difference for Allen is tight end Dalton Kincaid, who has been the most reliable weapon outside of Shakir. The numbers prove that having Kincaid in the lineup has been the key to unlocking Allen.
Bills Chat Podcast proved this by comparing Allen’s numbers in games with Kincaid to games without him. Allen is completing 71.7 percent of his attempts with a 13-to-3 touchdown-to-interception ratio with Kincaid. Without him, his completion percentage drops to 64.4, and Allen has five touchdowns and six interceptions.
Josh Allen Splits with/without Dalton Kincaid
Games with Dalton Kincaid (8)
Completion % 71.7
TD: 13
INT: 3
Games without Kincaid (3)
Completion percentage 64.4
TD: 5
INT: 6
— Bills Chat Podcast (@BillsChatPod) November 24, 2025Dalton Kincaid is Josh Allen’s No. 1 option
Buffalo Bills tight end Dalton Kincaid makes a catch for a touchdown in the first quarter against the Kansas City Chiefs | Gregory Fisher-Imagn Images
A first-round pick out of Utah, Kincaid has emerged as a playmaker this season. In eight games, he has 29 receptions for 448 yards and a career-high four touchdowns. The main issue with Kincaid, however, is durability.
He missed four games in 2024 and was slowed by a knee injury throughout the season. This year, he’s missed three games, and the results speak for themselves.
SIGN UP: Get Bills OnSI straight to your inbox (for free)
Those results also prove the front office is making a mistake in their approach to roster building. By asking Allen to elevate every player around him, rather than getting him a true star, they’re holding their own team back.
This offseason, that approach has to change. Buffalo needs to find players outside of Kincaid and Shakir who can help Allen reach his full potential and take this team where it wants to go.
— Sign up for OnSI’s Free Buffalo Bills Newsletter —
What ever happened to injured NFL referee forced to leave Bills’ TNF loss to Texans?Ex-Bills’ personnel director says ‘just cut Keon Coleman’Is Josh Allen amongst seven current Bills’ players in Hallmark movie cast?Bills’ Michael Hoecht selects surgeon who operated on Aaron Rodgers, Kobe Bryant