Dan Johnson takes you through his preview, prediction, and pick for NFL Week 17’s game between the Indianapolis Colts and the Jacksonville Jaguars.

Week 17 lands like a fork in the road for both franchises, even with different maps in their hands. Jacksonville is 11–4 and already punched a playoff ticket, but it still chases the cleanest path through January. Indianapolis is 8–7 and now eliminated from the playoff picture, so the urgency shifts into evaluation, pride, and future stakes. Philip Rivers (QB) steps back into the league’s brightest lighting, and every throw carries a little history with it. Trevor Lawrence (QB) gets the opposite burden: turn a strong season into a ruthless finish. Below is my prediction for NFL Week 17’s game between the Indianapolis Colts and the Jacksonville Jaguars.

Here’s how I’ll play it. I’ll be pumping out these predictions for individual games all season, with plenty of coverage here on DraftKings Network. Follow my handle @dansby_edits for more betting plays.

The numbers start with quarterback environment and how each offense handles time. Lawrence nukes clean pockets lately at +0.451 EPA per dropback, and he stays functional when pressure arrives at -0.102. Rivers lives on rhythm and recognition, and he actually crushes blitz looks at +0.469 EPA per dropback, but pressure flips him into the red at -0.345. That’s why the Colts’ protection profile matters more than any vibe. Over Weeks 15–16, Rivers faced pressure on 13.9% of quick-game dropbacks, then ate pressure on 50.0% of standard dropbacks, with play-action sitting pristine at 0.0%. Jacksonville can smell that split. The Jaguars’ front barely touches quarterbacks who cut it loose in 2.5 seconds, but their pressure rate jumps to 41.4% in the 2.5–3.0 band and 55.7% once plays extend past three seconds. That clash makes the Colts’ plan obvious and fragile at the same time. Rivers wants the quick game and play-action to carry the day, because his time-to-throw distribution clusters between 2.0–2.5 seconds (40.3%) and 2.5–3.0 (27.4%). Lawrence holds it longer at 2.73 seconds, but he turns that patience into explosives. Over Weeks 13–16, he posted +0.834 EPA per dropback on throws out fast against single-high, and he still produced +0.496 with a 25.0% explosive rate in the 2.5–3.0 window versus two-high. He also roasted man coverage at +0.681 EPA per dropback with a 31.1% explosive rate, then stayed efficient versus zone at +0.419.

That efficiency has names, and the usage trees tell the story of who owns the steering wheel. Jonathan Taylor (RB) has carried the Colts through the rough water with eighty-three rushes and twelve targets from Weeks 13–16, plus twelve red-zone carries. The efficiency has not matched the workload, with a 38.6% success rate and a 7.2% explosive run rate behind a 37.0% run-block win rate. Indianapolis can still build long drives, but it cannot count on easy chunks in the run game. The passing game has leaned into Tyler Warren (TE) as the primary lever, with a 23.3% target share and seven red-zone targets over the last six. Michael Pittman (WR) still runs everything at 91.7% route participation with a 20.0% target share, while Josh Downs (WR) holds an 18.3% share on fewer routes. Jacksonville answers with a tighter hierarchy and sharper red-zone intent. Jakobi Meyers (WR) owns a 25.1% target share with 92.6% route participation, and Brenton Strange (TE) matches Meyers with eight red-zone targets despite a 66.2% route rate. That pairs cleanly with an Indianapolis defense that plays zone on 61.8% of snaps and bleeds the middle, allowing +0.220 EPA on throws between the numbers. Jacksonville can live in seams, crossers, and sit routes until Indy proves it can tackle and plaster.

Jaguars vs. Colts pick, best bet

The Colts cover case still exists, and it’s not a fairy tale. Rivers can keep the game quiet if he stays in quick answers, because Jacksonville’s pressure rate stays tame on throws out in 2.5 seconds. Taylor can also drag the Jaguars into patient football if Indianapolis stays on schedule and avoids third-and-long. The Colts’ recent red-zone profile supports that path, with a 62.5% red-zone touchdown rate over the last six and an 80.0% goal-to-go rate. Indianapolis also brings real hidden-yardage juice, posting +9.87 return EPA over the last eight games, and that can steal a short field without a turnover. If Jacksonville’s offensive line injuries force Lawrence into a quicker, flatter game, the Jaguars can trade some ceiling for security and still let the door stay cracked. That’s how a favorite fails to separate.

I still land on Jacksonville -5.5, because the scoring shapes favor the Jaguars and the leverage snaps tilt their way. Jacksonville has finished drives at a 70.6% red-zone touchdown rate over the last six with an 86.7% goal-to-go rate, and it has converted 55.6% of fourth downs while Indianapolis sits at 0.0% in that span. That fourth-down split changes the math in a game with a total this high, because it turns stalled drives into points and keeps the opponent’s offense cold. The total has also climbed to 48.5 after opening in the mid-forties, and that move asks Indianapolis to hold up its end of the bargain. Rivers can do it, but he needs structure to stay clean, because standard dropbacks invite the one thing he cannot survive. The roof removes weather chaos, so the better quarterback and the cleaner spacing plan usually win over time. I’ll lay the 5.5, and I’ll play it to -6.

Jacksonville should attack Indianapolis’ zone rules with layered middle-of-field concepts and force linebackers to declare. Lawrence should keep the ball on time early, because his ≤2.5-second efficiency versus single-high sits in the stratosphere. When Indy rotates to two-high, Lawrence should live in the 2.5–3.0 pocket where his explosives still spike. Indianapolis should counter with condensed formations, hard play-action, and quick-game sequencing that keeps Rivers out of the 50% pressure trap. Taylor should still get fed, but the Colts should treat him as a drive-lengthener, not a home-run plan. Warren should stay involved as the first-read chain mover, because Jacksonville’s pass rush punishes long-developing routes.

I’m calling Jaguars 27, Colts 20.

Best bet: Jaguars -5.5 (-115) at Colts

Tail it with me in the DKN Betting Group here!

I’m in on Tyler Warren (TE) 6+ receptions at +125, because the game plan and the coverage math both push targets into his lap. Over the last six, Warren leads Indianapolis with 42 targets and a 23.3% target share, and he’s also the red-zone focal point with seven red-zone targets and 29.2% of the team’s looks down there. Rivers has also played this exact kind of game lately: his Weeks 15–16 profile leans on quick timing, with 36 of 62 dropbacks coming in quick game, and his pressure rate drops to 13.9% when he lives there. That’s where Warren eats, because he’s the first-window answer against zone spacing and underneath defenders. Jacksonville can generate heat when plays extend, but that’s exactly why Rivers should keep the ball out fast and keep feeding the tight end. Even if the Colts fall behind, the comeback script still pushes volume to the middle of the field, and Indy’s target distribution already tells you who gets those “move-the-chains” throws. I expect a steady six-catch path here without needing a touchdown, and the +125 is paying for a workload that’s already been real.

Best prop lean: Tyler Warren 6+ receptions (+125)

Tail it with me in the DKN Betting Group here!