Getty
Cleveland Browns general manager Andrew Berry.
Core changes to the organization have defined the Cleveland Browns‘ offseason to this point, and one former NFL general manager turned analyst is advising the team make at least one more.
ESPN’s Mike Tannenbaum pitched a trade on Monday, February 23 flipping two-time Defensive Player of the Year Myles Garrett to the Detroit Lions in return for a massive haul of draft assets.
“[The Browns] are a ways away from competing in the AFC given the uncertainty at the quarterback position, amongst other places,” Tannenbaum said. “If [the Lions] have Aidan Hutchinson on one side and Myles Garrett on the other, with that offense, I think they get to the Super Bowl.”
Browns Could Likely Trade Myles Garrett for 2 First-Round Picks, Plus More
GettyCleveland Browns defensive end Myles Garrett.
ESPN’s Bill Barnwell wrote in July 2025 that Garrett was worth a first-round draft pick, plus more, in a trade. The pass-rusher then captured second DPOY award, this time unanimously, after breaking the league’s single-season sack record with 23 sacks. He also led the NFL with 33 tackles for loss.
Garrett will turn 31 near the end of next season, which could impact his trade value to some degree. But at this point, the Browns could probably deal Garrett at what would be his all-time high trade value.
The Lions pick 17th in the upcoming draft and have a good chance of being better in 2026, thus picking even later in the first round in 2027. So it wouldn’t be outside the realm of possibility for Cleveland to ask for (and receive) two first-rounders (2026, 2027) as well as another meaningful draft asset, likely to convey in 2026.
The Green Bay Packers flipped two first-round picks (2026, 2027) and three-time Pro Bowl defensive tackle Kenny Clark to the Dallas Cowboys for Micah Parsons, who has a similar skill set and resumé to Garrett, in August 2025.
Parsons is three and a half years younger than Garrett, but hasn’t actually produced at as high of a rate over their shared time in the league, so Parsons offers a good comparison of what the Browns might expect to get back in a deal for Garrett.
Cleveland probably isn’t a contender in either of the next two seasons, at which point Garrett’s value may begin to dip, which argues for turning him into three swings at high-quality youth talent who will play on rookie contracts through 2030.
Lions Have to Worry About Paying Their Own Players Before Adding Myles Garrett’s Massive Salary to Books
GettyRunning back Jahmyr Gibbs of the Detroit Lions.
Some might view Garrett’s recent extension, which came in at four years and $160 million and keeps him under contract through 2030, as a negative-value deal as he moves into the latter stages of his career.
However, Dan Graziano contended that it would still be worth it for Detroit, or any contending team, to make a move for Garrett. Graziano’s larger point, however, was that it makes sense for Cleveland to move on from the defensive end right now.
[A Garrett trade] makes sense to me, but it’s not something I’m hearing. The Browns still seem adamant that they don’t want to trade him. He is not making the same kinda noise he was making this time last year about wanting a trade.
While I feel like it makes sense for [Cleveland] to consider it given what you could probably get for this player, given that the extension they did for him last season doesn’t make the contract untradable in any real way, I think it’s something they should be looking at. It doesn’t sound like they are.
Graziano also mentioned the potential problems on Detroit’s side, namely the money the team is going to pay on extensions for star players across the roster, including running back Jahmyr Gibbs, tight end Sam LaPorta, safety Brian Branch and linebacker Jack Campbell.
All of those players from the 2023 draft class are extension-eligible this spring, but LaPorta and Branch have to get done this year or both players will become unrestricted free agents next offseason. The Lions hold fifth-year team options for 2027 on both Gibbs and Campbell as former first-round picks, which means the team can push those extensions off an extra year if need be.
“In terms of who says no to the Detroit move — the salary cap,” Graziano continued. “I think it sounds great, the idea of Myles Garrett in Detroit, but I don’t know how they pay for it.”
Max Dible covers the NFL, NBA and MLB for Heavy.com, with a focus on the Green Bay Packers, Minnesota Vikings, Chicago Bears and Cleveland Browns. He covered local and statewide news as a reporter for West Hawaii Today and served as news director for BigIslandNow.com and Pacific Media Group’s family of Big Island radio stations before joining Heavy. More about Max Dible
More Heavy on Browns
Loading more stories