Buccaneers' Early Free-Agency Haul Earns Passing Grade From PFF

The Tampa Bay Buccaneers didn’t necessarily dominate headlines during the opening wave of free agency. Maybe that was the error of some flawed reporting. They certainly stocked their cupboard with some impressive signings.

Their approach was both measured and patient. Sure, the said goodbye to a legend in wide receiver Mike Evans among others.

Still, the approach they elected to take has earned solid marks from one of the more talked about platforms dedicated to NFL content.

Pro Football Focus has its die-hard fans. There is also the contingent that believes their reporting should be taken with a grain of salt.

Here’s where most can agree. They always find a way to get a conversation started.

Take one of their latest digs, 2026 NFL free agency grades for all 32 teams. The Buccaneers received a ‘B’. This seems fair for a front office that has prioritized balance over making splash additions.

Jason Licht and his staff have added contributors at multiple positions while avoiding overly risky long-term commitments.

Five players are mentioned by Gordon McGuinness. He’s the writer of their story.

As he mentions, one of the more intriguing additions is running back Kenneth Gainwell. He steps into a backfield that is undergoing some transition. His ability to contribute as both a runner and receiver makes him a versatile complement to what Tampa Bay already has in place.

At linebacker, Alex Anzalone brings stability and experience. He’s not flashy, but he’s dependable. He’s capable of contributing on all three downs and fitting into multiple defensive looks. For a Buccaneers defense looking to maintain consistency, that kind of reliability carries real value.

The mention of Cade Otton’s return is where opinions begin to split. There are questions about whether the financial commitment matches the production.

Yes, he has been steady, but he has also been unspectacular at times. The hope is that familiarity within the system allows him to take another step forward.

Up front, the addition of A’Shawn Robinson feels like a depth move with some risk attached. He’s a seasoned veteran who can still contribute, but the price point suggests Tampa Bay is betting on a bounce-back of sorts, one he may not be able to provide.

Meanwhile, Al-Quadin Muhammad may quietly end up being one of the better value signings. Coming off a productive season, he adds pass-rush help without a major financial burden.

With all of that said, let’s make long stories shorter.

While the price tags offered to some of these players has raised some eyebrows, AQM’s recent production suggests he can justify the investment if utilized properly.

Grading this crop of additions by giving them a ‘B’ seems fair. No challenge flags will be thrown.

All things considered, this isn’t about winning headlines in March. This is about building functional and competitive roster.

The Buccaneers may not have made the loudest moves, but they made many of the more thoughtful ones. In a league where depth and flexibility often decide outcomes, that approach could pay off more than flash ever could.

Join our ROUNDTABLE community! It’s free to join. Share your thoughts, engage with our Roundtable writers, and chat with fellow members.

Download the free Roundtable APP, and stay even more connected!

Buccaneers’ Early Free-Agency Haul Earns Passing Grade From PFF

Tags: