Indianapolis Colts
Favorite Move: WR Alec Pierce
Admittedly, the Colts made a big investment in a wide receiver who has not truly had to play as a No. 1 option until this point. However, Pierce has been too valuable for the team to let him walk in free agency. Based on PFF Wins Above Replacement, Pierce was the 13th-most-valuable wide receiver in football last season, which lines up well with the Colts making him the 12th-highest-paid player at the position.
Least Favorite Move: QB Daniel Jones
The Colts did not have much leverage in this situation, and it was a foregone conclusion that they would need to stick with Jones, at least for the near future. On a positive note, they are committed to the quarterback for only two seasons. Still, making him the 13th-highest-paid quarterback in the league, at an average of $44 million per year over the next two seasons, is an overpay based on how the 2025 season ended. Despite a very strong start to his campaign, Jones ended up just the 21st-highest-graded quarterback (71.7).