The Pittsburgh Steelers are coming off of an AFC North division title and a home playoff game in 2025. Pittsburgh was embarrassed in its Wild Card matchup against the Houston Texans, and a huge reason was the rudderless offense that plagued the team for most of the season. The Steelers couldn’t find any rhythm in that game, and that was just a snapshot of their entire year. Steelers fans were left with a bad taste in their mouths, and a lot of it was because of the lack of offense.
Alysa Rubin / Pittsburgh Steelers
Steelers wide receiver DK Metcalf (4) during a postseason matchup between the Pittsburgh Steelers and Houston Texans.
The Steelers added star receiver DK Metcalf in a trade with the Seattle Seahawks ahead of the 2025 campaign, but the team then needed to look to add to its receiving corps after trading George Pickens.
The move to acquire Metcalf sent the team’s second-round pick to Seattle, and the team inked Metcalf to a four-year, $132 million extension. The franchise was looking for a long-term solution at receiver; however, the front office did very little to help Metcalf. The organization had Calvin Austin III, who is an undersized speedster, and Roman Wilson, who had yet to find significant playing time.
The offense had a clear lack of outside weapons, and this led to a passing game that found mediocre success. The Steelers’ 42-year-old signal caller relied on a subpar receiver room throughout the year, and the offense often had trouble clicking and relied on its defense to bail it out. Because of this, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s Brian Batko criticized Steelers General Manager Omar Khan on the North Shore Drive podcast.
“I think you could make a case that it was roster construction. It seemed like the Steelers’ front office underestimated their needs at receiver,” Batko said.
Pittsburgh’s roster was based around an aging quarterback on the verge of retiring, a star receiver with little around him, and a defense that was getting older. The Steelers’ brass didn’t realize the glaring issues that its roster had. These were often exploited during the season and really showed out on national television in the playoff game. The Steelers’ passing game ranked abysmally last year, being 22nd in the league. For a team that won its division, that was a bad metric.
Steelers.com / Youtube
Steelers’ Aaron Rodgers speaking with members of the Pittsburgh media following a win over the Colts in the 2025 NFL season.
The Steelers’ poor roster construction didn’t just stop on offense, though. The Black and Gold defense was the league’s highest-paid and oldest in 2025. The unit was ranked 26th in yards allowed per game. It struggled against the run at times, and this was clearly an issue with the roster again. Steelers defensive lineman Keeanu Benton is not a huge run-stopper, but he was put into that role often.
This is just one example of the Steelers not addressing a weakness, and he was often outmatched in the run game, despite being an effective pass-rusher. On both sides of the ball, the front office did little to rectify issues in the 2025 offseason, and it ended up being a huge problem.
The Steelers’ roster construction was poor in 2025 and was a huge reason that Steelers fans were left without a playoff win, yet again. The team hopes to find more balance and depth in 2026.
Steelers Have Made Better Choices Already This Offseason
The Steelers have been more aggressive than usual during the 2026 offseason. They made a trade that already makes their thin receiver room much better by trading for Michael Pittman Jr. They have made strides in their secondary, added another running back, and a true thumper at defensive line to stop the run. Pittsburgh has already remedied some of its huge weak points from last year, and the NFL Draft is right around the corner.
Marc Lebryk / Imagn Images
New Steelers wide receiver during his time with the Indianapolis Colts.
It seems the Steelers have already had a stronger offseason, in terms of acquisitions, than years past. If the team can put it all together, their roster looks better on paper than last year. They have openly addressed the issues that they had from last year, and will look to remain competitive in 2026.