Saw this post where someone ran AI analysis on Dan Brugler’s draft prospect list called ‘The Beast’ to find injury or off-the-field concerns. While the results were a mixed bag, I could tell the user was a bit of a novice using AI systems. But it was certainly a good start on something like that. I use AI every day at my day job as I work in tech, so I figured why not try something similar but with a Denver Broncos focus?

I’m in the early phases still and have a few more days to go before I’m even ready to proceed with publishing any results, but I have some early preliminary data and methodology that I figured wouldn’t hurt to share with the MHR community and get some feedback. Maybe I can improve the methodology from member feedback before running it all the way through…

Advertisement

More on that at the end of the Roundup. Let’s get to the news and other Broncos’ happenings first.

Broncos daily recap

What is the best way for the Broncos to approach the 2026 NFL Draft?
With no first-round pick on the board, Denver’s draft won’t really start until pick No. 62, but that might not be a bad thing in a class that’s loaded with Day 2 depth rather than top-heavy first-round talent. The Broncos’ recent track record with second-rounders — Nik Bonitto becoming an All-Pro edge rusher, Marvin Mims earning back-to-back All-Pro return honors, and RJ Harvey leading all rookies with 12 touchdowns in 2025 — suggests the front office knows how to find impact players on Day 2, whether they stand pat, move up, or trade back. The priority this time around should be finding someone who can step in and contribute immediately to a roster built for a Super Bowl push.

Under the radar

Our own Joe Mahoney dropped an interesting post today. Bo Nix faced man coverage the 5th-lease in the NFL, but was 4% better vs man over zone. Interesting.

From the FEED

Rpek dropped a few “Gotta have it” posts. Check them out!

Can AI predict Payton and Paton?

Okay, let’s down to it. First, I had AI investigate each and every draft George Paton and Sean Payton have had together, but then threw in two previous drafts before they joined forces. Their joint drafts obviously have higher correlation. After an exhaustive review of each drafted player in those seven drafts, which took a few sessions to complete, there were several key points of reference that helped identify what the duos draft tendencies followed.

Advertisement

Methodology:

Cataloged seven draft classes across Payton’s and Paton’s careers, plus nine shared-era UDFA signings

Weighted shared Broncos drafts (3x) higher than pre-partnership classes (1x) and UDFAs (1.5x)

Researched every historical pick’s pre-draft profile as it existed at the time of selection – Extracted weighted tendencies across physical, athletic, production, school, injury, character, and positional dimensions

Derived a 100-point scoring rubric empirically from the tendency data, not assumed up front

Applied hard gates for character red flags, significant medical history, roster duplication, and small-school validation

Audited the current Broncos roster to identify complementary gaps and duplication risks by position

Back-tested the rubric against actual historical picks to verify accuracy

Scored and tiered every 2026 prospect against the validated rubric

Using that data and methodology, the goal now is to review each and every position group from Dane Brugler’s beast of a draft prospect list. The goal was to put players into tiers that likely fit the Payton/Paton mold. So far, I’ve completed a test run of the running back position tonight and the results were interesting…

IMPORTANT NOTE: This analysis is SPECIFIC to the Broncos and their current draft capital. Not an actual big board for ALL teams.

Running Back Tier 1 — Highest Correlation (A, Bullseye)

Mike Washington Jr. (Arkansas, 3rd) — 6’1″/223 bruiser with class-best 4.33 speed, SEC production, Senior Bowl attendee, quiet-worker profile Paton loves; perfectly fills the bruiser gap and serves as Dobbins-insurance/Harvey complement the room desperately needs.

Kaytron Allen (Penn State, 4th) — 4-year 5’11″/216 starter, 4,000+ career yds (school record), blitz-pickup chops, Senior Bowl, zero missed games; exactly the between-the-tackles workload back (+3 complementary gap) to keep Dobbins fresh without duplicating Harvey.

Running Back Tier 2 — Solid Candidates (B, Strong Fit)

Kaelon Black (Indiana, 5th-6th) — 5’9″/211 muscled-up “Freaks List” alum with 4.45 speed and legit pass-pro tape; undersized in height but plays like a bruiser, fills gap as a low-cost power complement to Harvey.

Jam Miller (Alabama, 6th-7th) — 5’10″/209 Bama-trained “best worker on team” with 4.42 speed and ST value; between-the-tackles build fills complementary gap, though 2025 injury-driven production drop keeps him out of Tier 1.

Le’Veon Moss (Texas A&M, 6th) — 5’11″/211 SEC downhill grinder with red-zone production and strong character; +3 bruiser gap fit, though torn ACL + ankle issues pile onto an already injury-fragile backfield.

Nicholas Singleton (Penn State, 5th) — 6’0″/219 with home-run speed and KR value; size fits the complementary gap, but tunnel-vision inside running, pass-pro issues, and Senior Bowl foot surgery push him down.

Roman Hemby (Indiana, 7th) — 6’0″/208 four-year Maryland/Indiana starter, 129 career catches, low fumble rate; tweener build is roster-neutral and receiving volume plus STs give Payton a useful chess piece without duplicating Harvey.

Adam Randall (Clemson, 7th-FA) — 6’3″/232 former WR with 4.50 speed, KR experience, Senior Bowl captain; unique big-body frame fills +3 bruiser gap, ex-receiver hands give him a Payton-style third-down-plus-size profile.

Running Back Tier 3 — Maybes (C, Role Fit)

Emmett Johnson (Nebraska, 3rd-4th) — 5’10″/205 All-American with 46 catches in 2025 and crisp routes; −2 soft duplicate of Harvey/McLaughlin, but Big Ten RB of the Year production and receiving chops keep him relevant as Dobbins insurance.

Jadarian Price (Notre Dame, 2nd-3rd) — 5’11″/203 4.49 change-of-pace/KR specialist with zero college starts; −2 soft duplicate of Harvey (same school, same archetype, same KR role) drops him out of Tier 2 despite R2-R3 grade.

Chip Trayanum (Toledo, 7th-FA) — 5’11″/224 multi-school vet with 4.50 speed and LB background; fills complementary bruiser gap and the pass-pro/STs toughness fits Payton’s depth-back mold.

CJ Donaldson (Ohio State, FA) — 6’2″/236 all-gas downhill grinder, pass-pro upside, zero drops past two years; +3 bruiser gap fit, but 4.61 speed and 3.8 ypc senior year cap the upside.

Jonah Coleman (Washington, 4th-5th) — 5’8″/220 Academic All-American with pass-pro value Payton loves; height-based soft duplicate of Harvey even with the bruiser weight, and senior YPC slide hurts.

J’Mari Taylor (Virginia, 6th) — 5’10″/197 former walk-on, productive zone runner with Senior Bowl invite; −2 soft duplicate of Harvey, though bowling-ball short-yardage finishing gives a partial gap credit.

Barika Kpeenu (NDSU, FA) — 5’10″/213 FCS workhorse, 20 rushing TDs, Jerome Ford comp; fills complementary gap as low-cost bruiser depth, but 4.66 speed at FCS level makes him a fit-not-priority.

Noah Whittington (Oregon, 6th-7th) — 5’8″/205 tough zone runner, strong in pass pro; −2 soft duplicate of Harvey/McLaughlin, and ACL+turf toe durability compounds injury-room concern.

Star Thomas (Tennessee, FA) — 5’11″/200 multi-school transfer with 5.7 ypc in SEC backup role; −2 soft duplicate, but lateral creativity and no 2025 fumbles give depth-camp value.

Advertisement

Tier 4 — Unlikely (D/F, Off-Profile)

Jeremiyah Love (Notre Dame, 1st) — Heisman finalist/Doak Walker elite talent; hard-gated by Payton-Paton “never R1 RB” history — top talent but wrong round/position profile, not a roster-complement question.

Seth McGowan (Kentucky, 6th-7th) — 6’0″/223 would hit the bruiser gap; hard-gated by 2021 robbery/assault arrest and Oklahoma dismissal — Paton character screen eliminates.

Demond Claiborne (Wake Forest, 4th-5th) — 5’10″/188 burner compared to “diet Achane”; −2 soft duplicate of Harvey plus sub-190 frame, 2025 fumble issues, and soft pass-pro stack a hard “no.”

Eli Heidenreich (Navy, 5th) — Navy “Snipe Z” hybrid with service-academy commitment; off-type and roster-neutral, but position-unclear fit plus Navy service obligation is a non-starter for a 2026-need draft.

Max Bredeson (Michigan, 7th) — 6’2″/252 true FB/H-back with zero college carries; off-type for the RB room, fullback role Payton rarely employs, special-teams-only ceiling.

Rahsul Faison (South Carolina, 7th-FA) — 5’11″/206 26-year-old multi-stop JUCO vet; −2 soft duplicate of Harvey plus age gate (26 rookie year) plus pass-pro holes eliminate him.

Jaydn Ott (Oklahoma, 7th-FA) — 5’11″/198 former Cal star whose last two years cratered; −2 soft duplicate of Harvey plus explicit NFL scout questions on grit/toughness = Paton character red flag.

Robert Henry Jr. (UTSA, FA) — 5’9″/199 one-cut vet with big-play flashes; −2 soft duplicate of Harvey, undersized with ball-security and high-mileage issues.

Dean Connors (Houston, FA) — 5’11″/206 three-down receiving back, 147 career catches; −2 soft duplicate of Harvey/McLaughlin/Badie — clean athlete but the room already has three of him.

Desmond Reid (Pittsburgh, FA) — 5’6″/176 Sproles-comp return specialist; −2 hard duplicate of Harvey/McLaughlin — tiniest possible version of what the room already has, injury-prone on top.

Cash Jones (Georgia, FA) — 5’11″/185 Georgia walk-on, core-four ST profile; −2 soft duplicate of Harvey/Badie as passing-down/ST depth, lacks the between-tackles value the room actually needs.

The results were interesting as I said, but I feel there are gaps in its methodology that need to be filled before I can run this fully on every position group. While many players fit the mold, if they were too similar in size and ability to RJ Harvey then it is unlikely we’d see him get drafted by Denver. I also found it interesting that “Team Captain” is a huge deal with this duo and they never draft players with character concerns.

I’m open to getting feedback on this initial list and maybe firm up the methodology some before the real work begins over the next week and a half. I hope to just roll with the results ahead of the 2026 NFL Draft and find out if we were even in the ballpark come draft night.

It should be a fun exercise for me, anyway!