Say you are the HC or offensive playcaller for an NFL team. If you had to set your weekly game plan, which QB option would you choose?
Option 1: A QB that is limited, but will consistently deliver the same basic performance week and week out?
Option 2: A QB who one week might throw for 364 yards and 3 TDs, but then on another week throws three interceptions, barely completes 50 percent of his passes, and is sacked 5 times?
Which would you prefer? Consistency? Or living with the bad times because the occasional highs make up for it?