Wild things are happening in Carolina this year, and it’s not because of barbecue or the humidity, but rather the power of a single coin flipping in the air. The Panthers, a team that usually gives fans plenty to scratch their heads about, have managed to build a legend around the most random pregame ritual in football. According to every stat tracker who hasn’t wandered off in disbelief, the Panthers are 6-0 when they win the coin toss and 0-5 when they lose the coin toss this season, which means someone in Charlotte should probably start practicing sleight of hand.​

Game day in Bank of America Stadium feels like a Vegas roulette table. Cameras catch the intensity as usually mild-mannered linemen stare down a silver disc, while the captains debate whether “heads” is lucky, or if “tails never fails.” When the referee finally makes his call and lets that coin spin, fans everywhere cross their fingers, and some bet actual money. In contrast, others pray because this coin is apparently more important than anything else happening on the field.​

It’s gotten so dramatic that the Panthers should probably head home right after the toss. Forget the four quarters, skip the nachos, and start prepping for the parade if they win it. Every time the coin lands their way, they morph into an unbeatable juggernaut, ripping off wins whether it’s a divisional clash or a cross-country battle in Seattle. But oh, get ready for heartbreak if the coin falls on the opposition’s side. They could be squaring off against a team of toddlers and still get dropped without mercy. Some joke they oughta flip that coin before boarding the team plane, to save on travel costs and emotional distress.​

Players swear they aren’t superstitious, but you can see coaches squinting at coins during practice, trying to decipher if switching to a new coin would change their luck. Social media is in hysterics, and the stats departments are baffled. If Carolina keeps this up, maybe the secret is less about game plans and more about slipping the referee a “lucky” coin. Fans might just start a petition to play a best-of-seven coin toss series and skip the football altogether.​

In a season full of surprises, the Carolina Panthers might just be the only team in NFL history whose MVP is the coin itself. Someone get that thing a jersey.