In hindsight, the Cincinnati Bengals had a rollercoaster of a 2025 NFL draft class.

Fans know about the struggles of first-round pick Shemar Stewart and linebackers Demetrius Knight and Barrett Carter.

Advertisement

But the Bengals also got a fantastic rookie debut from guard Dylan Fairchild, who played a key role in forming the best offensive line of the Joe Burrow era.

Zooming out, here’s a quick look at Bengals rookie grades from Pro Football Focus:

Bengals rookie grades

Demetrius Knight Jr., LB: 41.4

RELATED: Bengals draft outlook: The last 10 picks at No. 10 overall

Fairchild’s grade actually ranked fifth among all rookie guards. The Bengals are hoping that the effort to rebuild midseason with rookie linebackers pays off with much higher grades next year.

And Stewart, the first-rounder, had multiple injury issues after the stunted offseason, so likewise, they’re hoping the grade takes a big jump next year.

Advertisement

Of note on limited snaps, Howard Cross graded at a 48.3 on the defensive line and cornerback Bralyn Lux had a 73.7 on a small sample size, so they’re pieces potentially sticking around for a while.

RELATED: Bengals players who regressed the most in 2025

This article originally appeared on Bengals Wire: Bengals rookie grades feel incomplete going into critical offseason