CLEVELAND, Ohio — Almost a year later, Browns GM Andrew Berry can admit how unlikely of a scenario it was.
“I guess maybe by way of example, if we were sitting here last year and you would’ve said, ‘Hey, look, you’re going to take a running back in an off-the-ball linebacker in the early second round,’ I would have said, ‘OK, that’s probably unlikely based on the player markets, that type of thing.’
“But that’s what we did because we felt like Carson (Schwesinger) and Quinshon (Judkins) made the most sense in that moment and they could be long-term fixtures on the roster.”
The former, Schwesinger, just won the NFL’s AP Defensive Rookie of the Year award on Thursday, becoming only the second player in franchise history to do so.
His award win was a big bet paying off for Cleveland, after taking the UCLA product at No. 33 overall — what Berry was alluding to on Tuesday, when he spoke following new head coach Todd Monken’s intro presser.
Schwesinger went from a walk-on at UCLA to a one-year starter in 2024. Appearing in 12 games with 10 starts, he was a consistent finisher and led the nation with 90 solo tackles and 7.5 solo tackles per game.
That output caught the attention of the Browns, who hadn’t made a significant investment at off-the-ball linebacker since drafting Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah in 2021.
He proved them right by becoming an immediate contributor.
He led all NFL rookies in tackles (146) and tackles for loss (11). Schwesinger also had 2.5 sacks, two interceptions, three passes defensed and 10 special teams tackles in 16 games, all starts.
More importantly, he was a key part of what so far has proved to be Berry’s strongest draft class, a group that also features defensive tackle Mason Graham, tight end Harold Fannin Jr., Judkins, and quarterback Shedeur Sanders, who will be in the thick of the race for the starting QB job this season.
A majority of those players should be “long-term fixtures” on the roster, as Berry said.
But now, the real work is beginning.
The Browns, and Berry, will have to try and copy that 2025 output in a “what have you done for me lately?” league.
The Browns have undergone sweeping changes this season, firing head coach Kevin Stefanski after a 5-12 year and eight wins in the last two years.
They’ve hired Todd Monken, and have said repeatedly they will devote a lot of resources, whether it be in the draft, free agency, or the trade market, to fixing the offensive side of the ball.
The Browns are up to 10 picks now in the 2026 draft to try and strike gold again, including two first-round picks — their own at No. 6 and Jacksonville’s at 24.
Right now, Cleveland is straddling two worlds. They have several older players, including Myles Garrett, who won his second NFL Defensive Player of the Year award on Thursday, and Denzel Ward, who are still in their primes. They have a strong group of second-year players, and will have, hopefully, more immediate contributors coming in the class of 2026.
But still, Berry said he projects the Browns to be one of the youngest teams in football in 2026.
“That’s just where we’re projecting based on the amount of draft resources we have and then probably just anticipated activity in free agency,” Berry said this week. “That combined with having a very young defense, we would anticipate that we’d be a very young team. We’re not necessarily going to be in the phase where we’re going to sign a bunch of mid-30s veterans to put us over the top so to speak.”
As the Browns have gotten younger on defense, they’ll turn and try to do the same thing on offense, particularly among their pass catchers and rebuilding an aging O-line. As far as QB, it may not be the best year to find a long-term answer. The sixth pick isn’t high enough for one of the top prospects in this year’s class, and there won’t be many free agency options.
That’s the tightrope Berry is walking now — balancing patience with urgency, youth with expectation. The roadmap hasn’t been a secret — Cleveland is in the middle of a rebuild, it’s just not a rebuild in the traditional sense.
“I think when people hear the term rebuild, and probably specifically here, really their thought is tear down, the idea that you’re trading away a number of prime players or veterans and you’re accumulating resources and things of that nature,” Berry said last month after Kevin Stefanski was fired.
“When we think about where we are in our transition, it really is about building up the offense. Many of the trades that we’ve made are really about maybe players who won’t be a part of the future core and getting future value for when we’re in our prime window with this roster.”
Schwesinger’s rise proved how important it can be to recognize talent regardless of position, even when the board doesn’t look the way conventional wisdom says it should.
The challenge now is doing it again, across the roster, and doing it fast enough to matter.
Because Defensive Rookie of the Year trophies are nice.
But draft classes that change the trajectory of the franchise are better.
Football Insider newsletter free trial: Take a minute and sign up for a free trial of our Football Insider newsletter, featuring exclusive content from cleveland.com’s Browns reporters.