Getty
When a name like Tyreek Hill hits free agency, the internet instantly tries to attach him to contenders, and right now, “Tyreek Hill 49ers” is one of the combinations people are actively searching.
There isn’t a direct report tying Hill to San Francisco. But the question is fair to ask because (1) he’s available, (2) the 49ers always live in the “win-now” lane, and (3) Hill still has the kind of skillset that can change how defenses play… if he’s healthy.
Hill was released by Miami on Feb. 16, per multiple reports, and he’s coming off a significant knee injury from late September.
The Miami Dolphins are releasing WR Tyreek Hill, per @AdamSchefter
YES/NO- should the #49ers sign him!?
Why the 49ers question makes sense right now
The cleanest argument for San Francisco isn’t “star hunting.” It’s fit.
Kyle Shanahan’s offense is built on creating stress: motion, play-action, YAC throws, and forcing defenders to hesitate for half a second. Hill’s speed does that by itself, and it’s why even a 32-year-old version (Hill turns 32 on March 1, per Pro Football Talk) still draws attention from teams looking for one more explosive piece.
The 49ers also know what it’s like when defenses can squat on routes and dare you to win over the top. Hill changes spacing. Even when he doesn’t get the ball, safeties have to play honest.
The biggest hurdle: health, and how the contract would need to work
If you’re writing the pros-and-cons list, the “con” starts with one word: medical.
ESPN reported Hill suffered a dislocated knee and tore multiple ligaments (including his ACL) on Sept. 29, 2025, requiring surgery. That’s why the contract structure matters more than the headline.
Pro Football Talk specifically raised the idea that Hill could sign before he’s fully cleared, and that teams may want protections tied to eventually passing a physical.
So if the 49ers were to explore this, the logical framework looks like:
Short-term commitment
Per-game active bonuses
Roster/physical protections
Real production Incentives (yards/catches/playtime/postseason)
That’s the only way this becomes a football move instead of a vibes move.
Where Hill would actually fit in the 49ers’ offense
A Hill signing wouldn’t be about replacing one specific receiver. It would be about giving Brock Purdy an answer when defenses load up on timing throws and clog the middle.
San Francisco’s current depth-chart listings show a wideout room that can shift quickly year to year, with names like Jauan Jennings and Ricky Pearsall among the listed starters in ESPN’s depth chart.
Even in his “down” 2024 by his standards, Hill still posted 81 catches for 959 yards and 6 TDs across 17 games. And the bigger picture is hard to ignore: Hill’s NFL.com career receiving line shows 819 receptions, 11,363 yards, and 83 receiving touchdowns. He’s also a Super Bowl champion.
Hill’s value would be in:
Creating explosive plays without perfect protection (speed wins fast)
Opening space for the underneath game (crossers, screens, option routes)
Tilting coverage pre-snap (motion tells you man/zone, forces adjustments)
And yes, the “49ers way” also matters: if Shanahan believes a player can be used as a weekly matchup weapon, he’ll find the touches.
Why it might not happen
Even if the football fit works, the market might not.
NFL Network reported Hill is expected to have a list of teams interested now that he can sign anywhere. And Pro Football Talk rattled off multiple potential suitors that “should give Hill a look,” which is a reminder San Francisco wouldn’t be bidding in a quiet room.
The other issue is philosophy: the 49ers can absolutely chase one big swing, but they also often need to spread resources across multiple spots, and Hill’s injury timeline could keep things cloudy into the spring.
The bottom line
Should the 49ers sign Tyreek Hill? Only if it’s priced and structured like a calculated upside bet, not a superstar splurge.
If the medical checks out and the deal is heavy on availability-based pay, Hill’s speed in Shanahan’s system is the kind of “one move changes the geometry” addition that can actually be worth the risk. If not, San Francisco can still get faster and deeper at wide receiver without betting real money on a 32-year-old coming off a major knee injury.
Erik Anderson is an award-winning sports journalist covering the NBA, MLB and NFL for Heavy.com. He also focuses on the trading card market. His work has appeared in nationally-recognized outlets including The New York Times, Associated Press , USA Today, and ESPN. More about Erik Anderson
More Heavy on 49ers
Loading more stories