Getty

DENVER, COLORADO – JANUARY 04: Bo Nix #10 of the Denver Broncos and Head coach Sean Payton of the Denver Broncos speak in the second quarter against the Los Angeles Chargers at Empower Field At Mile High on January 04, 2026 in Denver, Colorado. (Photo by C. Morgan Engel/Getty Images)

Sean Payton made one of the biggest decisions of his Broncos tenure on Tuesday. The tone of the reaction around the league was very telling.

After Payton confirmed that offensive coordinator Davis Webb will handle playcalling duties in 2026, the response across the NFL world centered on Payton’s willingness to step aside.

For a coach who has called plays since 2006, it marked a defining shift. And many saw it as a selfless one.

Broncos analyst Zack Kelberman summed up the sentiment bluntly.

“Gotta give Sean Payton a ton of credit for looking in the mirror and realizing it’s in the best interests of the Broncos to surrender playcalling,” Kelberman wrote. He added that for Payton, the move required “an unbelievable amount of ego-checking and pride-swallowing” and called it “the correct decision.”

Gotta give Sean Payton a ton of credit for looking in the mirror and realizing it’s in the best interests of the #Broncos to surrender playcalling.

For Payton in particular, this entails an unbelievable amount of ego-checking and pride-swallowing — things that didn’t seem

That framing quickly gained traction. This was not a coach forced into change. This was a coach choosing it after finishing 14-3 and coming within one game of the Super Bowl.

Broncos See Rare Change From Sean Payton 

Payton acknowledged at the NFL Combine that he had considered the idea during the season and finalized it after the Broncos’ AFC Championship loss to the Patriots.

Denver managed just 32 second half yards in that 10-7 loss without Bo Nix.

The offense stalled, and Payton later admitted he would start his self-evaluation with himself.

“I wouldn’t do it if I didn’t think it was going to help our team win,” Payton said. “It’s about improving your team any way you can.”

That quote fueled much of the positive reaction. Around the league, giving up playcalling is often viewed as an admission of failure. In this case, it was framed as growth.

Payton has faced criticism at times in his career for being stubborn or overly controlling, but this decision directly challenged that narrative.

Sean Payton Shows Full Belief in Davis Webb

ESPN insider Adam Schefter reported the notable change, while Jordan Raanan wrote, “Have said it many times. Davis Webb is a future star. Sean Payton knows it.”

The praise extended beyond Denver. Even Buffalo’s Joe Brady called Webb “an absolute stud” and noted how valuable it would be for a first time playcaller to have Payton as a resource.

Perhaps the strongest reaction came from the idea that Payton did not have to make this move.

The Broncos were top ten in offensive EPA and earned the AFC’s No. 1 seed in 2025.

Former NFL quarterback Chase Daniel pointed to the magnitude of the decision:

“I can’t fathom Sean Payton ever giving up play calling knowing how he operates,” Daniel posted. “And that should tell you everything you need to know about Davis Webb.”

Payton made it clear he will still be involved, but handing playcalling to Webb sends a different signal.

It shows trust, accountability, and the willingness to adjust if it gives the Broncos a better chance to win.

For a coach long viewed as controlling or even egotistical at times, this decision felt like a selfless move that embodied true leadership, and the reaction around the league reflected that.

More Heavy on Broncos

Loading more stories