When the NHL Network released its Top 20 Defensemen Right Now list, it was bound to stir conversation, but few expected Rasmus Dahlin’s placement to become such a flashpoint among fans. The Buffalo Sabres’ captain landed at No. 7, and while some praised the ranking, many fans, especially in Buffalo, felt it didn’t fully reflect just how dominant the 25-year-old has become.
Dahlin’s 2023–24 season speaks for itself. In 73 games, he racked up 68 points (17 goals, 51 assists), averaged 24:14 of ice time per night, and posted 21 power-play points. He also brought a physical edge with 101 hits and 98 blocked shots, proving he’s far more than just an offensive threat. This was his fourth straight season with at least 50 points and 20 power-play points, a level of consistency most defensemen never reach.
Rasmus Dahlin’s Surprising Spot on NHL Network’s Top 20 Defensemen List Sparks Debate
Fans argue for a higher ranking because Dahlin has mastered the balance between offensive risk-taking and defensive responsibility. Early in his career, he sometimes forced plays that led to turnovers.
Now, he’s far more selective, picking his spots wisely, a growth that has earned him heavy minutes in all situations, from penalty kills to quarterbacking the top power-play unit.
Fans are voicing their displeasure with the position given to Dahlin, making their opinions clear. One of them wrote, “Dahlin is top 5, I don’t even think it’s a conversation either.”
Another fan added, “Dahlin is without a doubt the 3rd best dman in the league.” Echoing the sentiment, another fan said, “Dahlin is top 3 argue with a wall,” while another pointed out, “Werenski is not better than Dahlin.”
Another fan mentioned ”•Heiskanen too high •Faber overrated •Dahlin too low •I’d want Forsling before I’d want McAvoy”
There’s also the leadership factor. As the captain of the Sabres, Dahlin isn’t just putting up numbers; he’s setting the tone for a young, talented roster still chasing its first playoff berth in over a decade. His poise, toughness, and playmaking have made him the face of Buffalo’s blue line and a central figure in their long-term plans.
Still, the NHL Network’s list placed him behind names like Cale Makar, Quinn Hughes, and Josh Morrissey, sparking the question: Is Dahlin undervalued compared to his peers?