Matthew Knies sparks debate after surprising comments about Maple Leafs star teammate William Nylander over the weekend (Getty Images) The Toronto Maple Leafs are heading into training camp with one of the biggest questions of the offseason: who will join Auston Matthews and Matthew Knies on the team’s top line? While many insiders see newcomer Matias Maccelli as the early favorite, Knies sparked debate over the weekend by subtly suggesting William Nylander as his preferred choice. His remarks, though casual, may have raised eyebrows within the organization.
Matthew Knies comments on William Nylander spark debate
At a meet-and-greet event partnered with Tylenol, Knies hinted that he would like to skate alongside Matthews and Nylander to open the season. On paper, the idea makes sense. Nylander has a proven track record of chemistry with Matthews, and he also logged nearly 60 even-strength minutes with Knies last year. The trio could easily become one of the most dangerous first lines in the league.However, the optics of Knies lobbying for a linemate are less straightforward. At just 22 years old and entering his third NHL season, Knies hasn’t fully cemented himself as a voice in lineup decisions. His outspoken nature isn’t new—he has previously called out teammates, including himself, when effort levels dipped—but this instance feels different. Suggesting who should play alongside him can be viewed as stepping into territory usually reserved for the coaching staff. Head coach Craig Berube will ultimately decide, and Knies may need to show he’s willing to adapt regardless of who fills that spot.
Balancing the Leafs’ top line without weakening the second line
If Berube were to grant Knies his wish, the Leafs would boast a premier top line, but it would come with complications. Shifting Nylander away would leave captain John Tavares with two new wingers. At 34, Tavares is still productive, yet forcing him to carry a heavier offensive and defensive load isn’t ideal for long-term success.That’s why GM Brad Treliving continues exploring options on the trade market to bolster the top six. Until then, Toronto has multiple internal candidates ready to audition beside Matthews and Knies in preseason. Nylander may be the obvious choice, but the Leafs’ challenge is building not just one elite line—but two balanced ones capable of surviving an 82-game grind.Also Read: Vancouver Canucks’ identity at crossroads as Quinn Hughes trade talk intensifies with Devils showing strong interest