Mitch Marner’s departure from the Toronto Maple Leafs after nine seasons created a massive void that has hockey fans questioning whether the team can remain competitive.
With nearly a quarter of fans predicting Toronto will take the biggest step back in the league, all eyes have turned to the remaining core players. But one former teammate might be ready to prove those doubters wrong.
Can William Nylander Fill the Leadership Void Left by Mitch Marner’s Exit?
The dissolution of Toronto’s famed “Core Four” marked the end of an era. When Marner left for the Vegas Golden Knights, he took with him nine seasons of chemistry and production that won’t be easily replaced. Now the “Core Three” of Auston Matthews, John Tavares, and William Nylander must shoulder greater responsibilities in the 2025-26 campaign.
According to James Mirtle, the fans’ skepticism stems from management’s inability to replace the standout winger adequately. However, Nylander’s offseason achievements suggest he’s preparing to step into a larger role. The 29-year-old has already been turning heads with his recent accolades and rising recognition throughout hockey world.
Pierre McGuire believes Nylander is poised for his best season yet. The Swedish winger has had an exceptional offseason, earning the prestigious Golden Puck award, Sweden’s highest honor for hockey players. Additionally, he claimed the fifth spot on the NHL’s list of top 20 wingers, positioning himself just behind Marner at number five.
How Has William Nylander Already Surpassed His Former Core Four Teammate?
The momentum continues to build for Nylander’s breakout campaign. In EA Sports’ latest rankings, he has officially overtaken Marner among the top 10 right-wingers in the NHL. This recognition reflects his steady climb up the league’s elite rankings.
While Nikita Kucherov of the Tampa Bay Lightning maintained his top position and Mikko Rantanen of the Dallas Stars held steady in the top five, Nylander climbed the rankings. He now sits directly behind Florida Panthers’ Sam Reinhart, having leapfrogged his former Core Four teammate in the process.
READ MORE: Oilers Surprisingly Snubbed in NHL Network’s List of the Top 20 Wingers
The statistics back up Nylander’s rising profile. Over the past three seasons, he has evolved into one of the league’s most consistent performers. His playoff production particularly stands out, having recorded 15 points across 13 games in the most recent postseason. That kind of clutch performance demonstrates the elevated play Toronto desperately needs.
Appearing on “Toronto Sports Rush,” McGuire expressed confidence in Nylander’s trajectory: “I think he brings a whack of confidence into this season. I don’t know if he’s going to play with John Tavares, I don’t know if he’s going to play with Auston Matthews, that’ll get sorted out in training camp and as the season goes along. But he’s one of those players who could even go another level higher.”
The versatility McGuire mentions could prove crucial for Toronto’s success. With increased ice time and responsibility, Nylander has the opportunity to showcase his complete skill set alongside either of his remaining core teammates. His recent string of achievements suggests he’s ready to embrace the challenge and potentially silence the doubters who question Toronto’s direction after Marner’s departure.