Dallas Stars forward Jason Robertson (21) looks on during an away game against the Toronto Maple Leafs.
When an insider like Nick Kypreos drops a bombshell on Sportsnet, Leafs Nation listens. The latest buzz isn’t just a depth move; it’s a franchise-altering concept. The rumor? The Toronto Maple Leafs making a massive offseason pitch for Dallas Stars superstar Jason Robertson.
On the surface, it sounds like fan fiction. Robertson is currently tied with Kyle Connor as the highest-scoring American (52 points) and is the heartbeat of the Dallas offense. But dig deeper, and the logic starts to form. Robertson is a restricted free agent (RFA) with arbitration rights this July, and rumors suggest he could seek a contract north of $12 million annually.
That is a number the Dallas Stars, already tight against the cap, might simply refuse to pay. This creates a rare window of opportunity for Brad Treliving. But be warned: the cost isn’t just money. It would likely cost Toronto their top prospect, Easton Cowan. Is the potential arrival of an elite scorer worth mortgaging the future? Let’s break down the reality of this blockbuster scenario.
The concept of Jason Robertson wearing Blue and White is tantalizing. We are talking about an elite play-driver, a proven goal scorer, and a player who fits the timeline of Auston Matthews and William Nylander perfectly. However, the mechanics of this deal are complicated, and as an analyst, I have to look at the “pain” side of the ledger first.
The Cost of Acquisition: Goodbye Easton Cowan?
The Maple Leafs do not have an overflowing cupboard of assets. We know they reportedly dangled Easton Cowan last season in a failed bid for Brayden Schenn—a move that, in hindsight, Leafs fans should be grateful didn’t happen. Cowan’s stock has only risen since then. If Dallas is going to move a 26-year-old superstar entering his prime, they aren’t doing it for draft picks in 2028. They want immediate, high-ceiling help.
To get Robertson, Toronto starts the conversation with Easton Cowan and likely adds defensive prospect Ben Danford, plus a first-round pick or a roster player to make the money work. Losing Cowan is a jagged pill to swallow. He represents cost-controlled skill, something the Leafs are desperate for. However, “prospects are cool, parades are cooler.” If you can flip a potential star for a guaranteed superstar, you usually make that call.
Why the Dallas Stars Might Actually Move a Superstar
Why would Dallas do this? It comes down to the cold, hard salary cap. The Stars are contenders, but they are facing a financial wall. If Robertson’s camp digs in at $12M—pricing him out of Texas—Dallas has to pivot. They cannot lose him for nothing, and they cannot let negotiations bleed into next season.
My Personal Insight
Here is my take: Don’t expect this to happen before the NHL trade deadline. The Stars are all-in for the Stanley Cup this year. Trading their best offensive weapon now would be suicide for their title hopes. But come July 1? All bets are off.
There is also the human element that analytics often miss: Nick Robertson. The Leafs currently have Jason’s younger brother. While Nick’s tenure in Toronto has been rocky, the allure of playing with his superstar brother could be a massive retention tool for both players. A “Robertson & Robertson” line isn’t just a marketing dream; it’s a chemistry experiment worth trying.
The Leafs would be entering a bidding war, no doubt. But if the cap math in Dallas forces a sale, Toronto needs to be the first team on the phone.
Finding the latest Toronto Maple Leafs news
Make sure to add nhltraderumor.com to your bookmarks immediately. We are your daily hub for breaking Toronto Maple Leafs news, deep-dive analysis, and confirmed starting goalies. Want to test your knowledge against other fans? Join our daily Fantasy Hockey Pool for a chance to win cash prizes! Also, check our “Game Day” section to find out exactly how to watch the Leafs game on TV today in your region. Don’t miss a beat—sign up for the newsletter below.