First-Round Pick Dilemma: Sherwood & Andersson Trade Tal

With the March 6 deadline closing in fast, two names dominate the rumor mill: Kiefer Sherwood and Rasmus Andersson.The problem? Teams are balking at the asking prices—specifically, first-round picks.

The 29-year-old winger has been a revelation in Vancouver. Playing on a $1.5M bargain deal, Sherwood brings grit, speed, and timely offense. The Rangers and Maple Leafs appear to be the most serious suitors, with the Ducks, Bruins, and Sharks also kicking tires.

A legitimate top-pairing right-shot defenseman, Andersson has 25 points in 39 games and is a pending UFA making $4.55M. The Leafs, Stars, Golden Knights, and Kings have all shown interest, but most want an extension in place.That’s where things get complicated—teams are being told Andersson wants to test free agency regardless of where he’s traded. Without an extension, the rumored price of two first-round picks becomes nearly impossible to justify.

Vancouver is asking for a first-round pick for Sherwood—possibly more. Calgary, meanwhile, is seeking a first-rounder plus a quality prospect for Andersson. The Canucks would also like to re-sign Sherwood, though it’s increasingly clear he may generate the better return.

First-round picks are more valuable than ever, but history shows that once you get past the top half of the round, outcomes become far less predictable. In recent years, we’ve seen plenty of late firsts moved at the deadline—and there’s reason to believe that trend will continue here.

WHY SOME TEAMS MIGHT PAY UP

Championship windows close fast.

Dallas desperately needs right-shot defense help, and Andersson could be the missing piece.Despite their sluggish seasons,,,The Rangers and Leafs are firmly in win-now mode, and Sherwood’s playoff-style game fits exactly what’s needed—especially to get past Florida in the East.

For Andersson specifically, teams are betting on 7–8 years of a true top-pair defenseman in his prime. That kind of long-term value explains the steep price. Quality right-shot defensemen almost never hit the market—and when they do, they aren’t cheap.