Craig Berube calls on Maple Leafs to improve at home (Image via: Getty Images) Craig Berube believed the Toronto Maple Leafs were turning a corner. A productive road trip had briefly steadied a team navigating a tight Eastern Conference playoff race, and a return to Scotiabank Arena was supposed to build momentum. Instead, Toronto’s ongoing struggles at home came back, creating bigger worries about the team’s confidence, execution, and sense of urgency at this important stage of the season.Sunday’s 4-1 loss to the Colorado Avalanche wasn’t just another defeat. It marked the Maple Leafs’ fourth straight home setback and extended a troubling slide that has erased much of the goodwill built earlier in January. With the standings tightening and the margin for error shrinking, Toronto is again searching for answers that haven’t come easily.
Toronto Maple Leafs’ home-ice struggles highlight execution problems
NHL Highlights | Avalanche vs. Maple Leafs – January 25, 2026
Colorado struck early, with Brock Nelson scoring twice in the opening eight minutes, forcing Toronto into chase mode almost immediately. From there, the Avalanche executed like an elite team: controlling the pace, limiting mistakes, and capitalizing on every lapse. The 4-1 defeat highlighted the Maple Leafs’ ongoing inability to sustain structure and compete consistently at home.Craig Berube was blunt afterward, emphasizing execution and battle level over systems or tactics. “You’re paid to play in the NHL, you gotta go out and play. Confidence comes from just hard work. Confidence comes from just playing the system, being direct. Confidence comes from work and compete,” Berube said, pointing to the mental toll of recent home losses. The coach also acknowledged that repeated defeats at Scotiabank Arena have started to weigh on the team’s mindset.The standings underscore the urgency. Toronto entered January in a wild-card spot but now sits 11th in the Eastern Conference with a .548 points percentage. After an impressive stretch where the Maple Leafs went 8-0-2 over 10 games, they have dropped six of their last seven, including four straight home defeats. These losses have been especially costly in a tightly contested Atlantic Division playoff race.Players mirrored Berube’s concerns. Jake McCabe admitted confidence has been fleeting, while captain Auston Matthews cited slow starts and costly mistakes as key factors in recent defeats. Even when Toronto begins games with energy, breakdowns quickly undo progress, forcing the team into reactive play.Veteran John Tavares said the team needs to stay consistent with their positioning and how they handle the puck. Goalie Joseph Woll added that the locker room still believes in the team, but finding momentum has been tough. With 52 games already played and a big matchup against Buffalo coming before the Olympic break, the team doesn’t have much time to get back on track.Berube made it clear that no single player can fix the problems. The team will need to respond together, improve their execution, compete harder, and stay mentally strong to turn this rough stretch into a positive or risk falling further behind in the playoff race.