By: Kim Smith Published 01/29/2026, 07:10 AM ET 
The New York Islanders make the short trip across town to face the New York Rangers on Thursday night at Madison Square Garden, with puck drop scheduled for 7:00 PM ET and the game airing on ESPN+. This rivalry matchup features two teams heading in very different directions as the season progresses. The Islanders enter as slight road favorites at -120 on the moneyline, while the Rangers are listed at even money on home ice. The total is set at 5.5 goals, with the over priced at -130 and the under at +110, and the puck line shows the Islanders at +1.5 (-258) against the Rangers at -1.5 (+210). With bragging rights and valuable points on the line, this Metropolitan Division clash carries extra intensity. Be sure to check out our free NHL picks for more daily NHL betting insights and expert analysis.
Sign Up for Winners and Whiners News Alerts, Get Exclusive Offers and Discounts
Subscribe Now
I understand that I can unsubscribe at any time. I have read and accepted the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy. I consent that Winners and Whiners may use third-party services to process my data.
Terms & Conditions New York Islanders Bringing Defensive Structure on the Road
The New York Islanders come into this matchup with a strong 28-19-5 overall record and have been particularly reliable away from home, posting a 14-10-3 road mark. The Islanders have leaned heavily on defensive structure and goaltending throughout the season, and that approach has translated into consistent results in hostile environments. Over their last five games, the Islanders have recently shut out the Flyers on the road, picked up a road win in Vancouver, and also suffered losses to Buffalo, Seattle, and Calgary. That stretch reflects a team capable of bouncing back quickly, especially after defensive lapses.
From a statistical standpoint, the Islanders are built to win low-scoring games. They average 2.81 goals per game while allowing just 2.71, one of the better defensive marks among Eastern Conference teams. Shot volume has been fairly balanced, with New York generating 27.7 shots per game and allowing 28.0, indicating a team comfortable absorbing pressure and limiting high-danger chances rather than dominating possession.
One area that stands out for the Islanders is their penalty kill. Operating at 82.8 percent, it has been a reliable unit all season, and the Islanders have not allowed a single shorthanded goal. While their power play has struggled at times, converting at just 15.9 percent, New York’s overall discipline and five-on-five structure allow them to stay competitive even when special teams do not provide a boost. In tight games, that defensive identity becomes their greatest asset.
New York Rangers Struggling to Find Home Ice Advantage
The New York Rangers enter Thursday night with a 22-25-6 overall record and have had significant difficulty at Madison Square Garden this season, posting a 6-13-4 home mark. Despite flashes of offensive talent, consistency has been elusive, particularly against disciplined defensive teams. In their last five games, the Rangers have recently beaten the Bruins in overtime and picked up a road win in Philadelphia, but they have also dropped games to San Jose, Los Angeles, and Anaheim. That inconsistency has made it difficult for New York to climb back into the playoff picture.
Statistically, the Rangers have struggled defensively. They are allowing 3.11 goals per game while scoring 2.66, a negative differential that has been reflected in their record. Shot generation has also lagged, with New York averaging just 26.0 shots per game while allowing 28.4. Those numbers suggest the Rangers often spend extended stretches in their own zone, particularly against teams that play structured, patient hockey.
Special teams have been a mixed bag for New York. Their power play has been effective at 22.1 percent, giving them a chance to stay competitive when games are called tightly. However, their penalty kill sits at 79.7 percent, and defensive breakdowns at even strength have repeatedly put pressure on their goaltending. While the Rangers are capable of offensive bursts, sustaining that production against defensively sound opponents has been a recurring challenge.
New York Islanders vs New York Rangers PickNew York Islanders vs New York Rangers Pick New York Islanders -120 (Moneyline)
The Islanders’ defensive consistency and strong road record make them the more trustworthy side in this matchup. New York has struggled to protect home ice, and the Islanders’ ability to limit high-danger chances plays directly into the Rangers’ offensive weaknesses. In a rivalry game that is likely to be tight and physical, the Islanders’ structure and patience give them the edge to grind out a road victory.
New York Islanders vs New York Rangers Total Pick
I’m backing the under here because the Islanders are comfortable slowing games down and forcing opponents into low-percentage looks. The Rangers’ offense has been inconsistent at even strength, and the Islanders’ penalty kill should neutralize New York’s biggest scoring advantage. With both teams likely to prioritize defensive responsibility early, this matchup sets up well for a game that stays below the 5.5-goal mark.
Final Score Prediction: New York Islanders 3, New York Rangers 2
This prediction was written before the completion of game play on Wednesday.
Spend $25 Get $50 in Coins
Show Bonus Code
Claim Bonus 
Get up to 103 SC + 20,500 GC for FREE with Legendz!
Show Bonus Code
Claim Bonus 
100% purchase match for up to 100 in Onyx Cash Free Picks
Show Bonus Code
Claim Bonus