Pittsburgh Penguins vs New York Islanders picks highlight a Tuesday night Metropolitan Division matchup that feels more like April than early February. With both teams packed tightly in the standings and playoff-style hockey expected, this game sets up as a tight margins battle that sharp bettors will be targeting closely in tonight’s NHL picks.
Sign Up for Winners and Whiners News Alerts, Get Exclusive Offers and Discounts
Subscribe Now
I understand that I can unsubscribe at any time. I have read and accepted the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy. I consent that Winners and Whiners may use third-party services to process my data.
Terms & Conditions Quick Picks and Prediction Moneyline Pick: Islanders -122 Total Pick: Under 5.5 Projected Final Score: Islanders 3, Penguins 2 Odds and Line Movement 
Opening Odds Team Moneyline Total Pittsburgh +106 Over 5.5 (-138) New York Islanders -128 Under 5.5 (+112) Current Odds Team Moneyline Total Pittsburgh -105 to +104 Over 5.5 (-138 to -140) New York Islanders -114 to -125 Under 5.5 (+112 to +116) Line Movement – Puck Line Date Time Pittsburgh NY Islanders Public ($, #) 02/03 08:16:27AM -105 -114 H 52%, H 80% 02/03 07:56:03AM +100 -120 H 52%, H 80% 02/03 07:55:22AM -102 -118 H 52%, H 80% 02/03 03:59:42AM +104 -125 H 52%, H 80% 02/02 10:25:31PM +105 -126 H 100%, H 100% 02/02 09:45:03AM +106 -128 Line Movement – Total Date Time Over Under Public ($, #) 02/03 08:16:27AM 5.5 (-138) 5.5 (+112) O 100%, O 100% 02/03 08:02:35AM 5.5 (-140) 5.5 (+112) O 100%, O 100% 02/03 08:02:33AM 6.5 (+114) 6.5 (-140) O 100%, O 100% 02/03 07:56:03AM 6.5 (+116) 6.5 (-142) O 100%, O 100% 02/03 03:59:42AM 5.5 (-142) 5.5 (+116) Penguins vs Islanders Key Matchups and Handicap
This game profiles as a controlled, low-event contest where New York is comfortable grinding out a result. The Islanders are built to keep games in the 3–2 range, relying on defensive layers and goaltending to frustrate opponents into mistakes.
Pittsburgh’s challenge is amplified by key absences. Without Kris Letang, the Penguins lose one of their most important transition defenders, making clean breakouts harder and putting more pressure on forwards to support the puck. Bryan Rust’s suspension also removes a critical top-six scorer and power-play threat, shrinking Pittsburgh’s margin for error.
The Islanders are not without injuries themselves, but their identity does not change. With Ilya Sorokin expected to handle the crease and New York focused on pace control, this sets up as a matchup where Pittsburgh must finish limited chances to win.
Betting Trends (PIT vs NYI) The Islanders are priced as a short home favorite despite near-equal standings. Pittsburgh has seen its offensive depth reduced due to injuries and suspension. Public betting has leaned heavily toward the Over early. New York consistently plays games decided by one goal. Key Injuries and Notes (PIT vs NYI) Kris Letang is out for Pittsburgh with a fractured foot. Bryan Rust is suspended for Pittsburgh. Semyon Varlamov remains on injured reserve for New York. Pierre Engvall, Alexander Romanov, and Kyle Palmieri are on injured reserve for New York. ATS and Total Picks Side: Islanders moneyline Total: Under 5.5 Final Score Prediction
This matchup should stay tight throughout, with New York’s structure and goaltending proving decisive late.
Projected Final Score: Islanders 3, Penguins 2
How to Bet Pittsburgh vs New York Islanders
This game is best approached by trusting New York’s ability to control pace at home rather than paying for a wide margin. The total is also inflated by public action, creating value on the under.
Compare pricing across the best sportsbooks and look for value using available sportsbook promo codes. Bettors who enjoy alternative formats can also explore social sportsbooks.
Taking advantage of offers like the bet365 bonus code and the fliff promo code can add extra value when betting close NHL matchups like this one.
Spend $25 Get $50 in Coins
Show Bonus Code
Claim Bonus 
Get up to 103 SC + 20,500 GC for FREE with Legendz!
Show Bonus Code
Claim Bonus 
100% purchase match for up to 100 in Onyx Cash Free Picks
Show Bonus Code
Claim Bonus