Islanders vs Devils picks headline tonight’s Metropolitan Division slate as New York heads to Prudential Center for a 7:00 PM ET puck drop against New Jersey. The betting market sees this matchup as razor-thin, but the underlying styles and injury situations tell a more specific story. I break down the odds, line movement, and matchup dynamics below, along with how I am betting this game. You can also find more daily value with my latest NHL picks.
Sign Up for Winners and Whiners News Alerts, Get Exclusive Offers and Discounts
Subscribe Now
I understand that I can unsubscribe at any time. I have read and accepted the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy. I consent that Winners and Whiners may use third-party services to process my data.
Terms & Conditions Quick Picks and Prediction Moneyline Pick: Islanders -110 Total Pick: Under 5.5 Projected Final Score: Islanders 3, Devils 2 Odds and Line Movement 
Opening Odds Team Moneyline NY Islanders -110 New Jersey -110 Total Over Under 5.5 -110 -110 Current Odds Team Moneyline NY Islanders -110 New Jersey -110 Total Over Under 5.5 -110 -110 Line Movement – Puck Line Date Time NY Islanders New Jersey Public ($, #) 02/05 05:02 AM -110 -110 NYI 50%, NJ 66% 02/05 05:01 AM -108 -111 NYI 50%, NJ 66% 02/05 03:16 AM -110 -110 NJ 100%, NJ 100% 02/04 10:29 PM -108 -111 02/04 05:23 PM -110 -110 02/04 03:18 PM -110 -110 02/04 10:28 AM -110 -110 Line Movement – Total Date Time Over Under Public ($, #) 02/05 05:01 AM 5.5 (-110) 5.5 (-110) OV 100%, OV 100% 02/05 03:16 AM 5.5 (-106) 5.5 (-114) 02/04 10:29 PM 5.5 (-110) 5.5 (-110) 02/04 10:39 AM 5.5 (-106) 5.5 (-114) 02/04 10:28 AM 5.5 (-110) 5.5 (-110) Islanders vs Devils Key Matchups and Handicap
This game profiles as a lower-event matchup driven by structure and patience. The Islanders are comfortable playing long defensive stretches, protecting the middle of the ice, and letting their goaltending dictate tempo. That approach directly challenges a Devils team that has struggled to consistently generate offense.
New Jersey’s injury situation magnifies that issue. Without Jack Hughes and with additional depth pieces sidelined, the Devils are missing the puck movement and finishing that normally fuels their transition game. Against a team that is content forcing one-and-done possessions, those absences matter.
From the New York side, the Islanders are not fully healthy either, but their offensive identity is less dependent on one creator. They rely more on forecheck pressure, depth contributions, and game management. That balance makes them more reliable in a tight, playoff-style contest.
The betting market reflects the uncertainty with both sides priced at -110, but stylistically this leans toward a close, lower-scoring game rather than a wide-open shootout.
NYI vs NJ Betting Trends The moneyline has held steady at -110 on both sides throughout the market cycle. Public betting has leaned toward New Jersey despite minimal line movement. The total has remained at 5.5 with brief juice swings rather than a number move. NYI vs NJ Key Injuries and Notes NYI: Kyle Palmieri remains on injured reserve. NYI: Calum Ritchie is listed out. NJ: Jack Hughes is out with a lower-body injury. NJ: Luke Hughes and Stefan Noesen are on injured reserve. Moneyline and Total Picks Moneyline Pick: Islanders -110 Total: Under 5.5 Final Score Prediction
Islanders 3, Devils 2
How to Bet
If you are betting this matchup, focus on discipline and price rather than chasing volatility. With the total holding at 5.5 and the side priced evenly, this is a spot where shopping lines matters. Make sure you are comparing options using trusted best sportsbooks and checking available sportsbook promo codes.
For bettors who prefer alternative platforms, social sportsbooks offer another way to approach lower-total games like this one. If you are signing up, options such as the bet365 bonus code or the fliff promo code can add extra value before puck drop.
Spend $25 Get $50 in Coins
Show Bonus Code
Claim Bonus 
Get up to 103 SC + 20,500 GC for FREE with Legendz!
Show Bonus Code
Claim Bonus 
100% purchase match for up to 100 in Onyx Cash Free Picks
Show Bonus Code
Claim Bonus