Some days, it feels like the Toronto Maple Leafs are trying to juggle with one hand tied behind their back. Injuries, depth issues, and a blue line held together with tape have forced the team to get creative. And with the trade deadline three weeks away, every decision—big or small—feels like it carries extra weight.
Related: Today in Hockey History: Feb. 13
In today’s Maple Leafs News & Rumours, I’m focusing on a prospect pushing for his shot, a high-end defenceman linked to Toronto (again), and one of the biggest ironies of the Maple Leafs’ season. There’s a reason why this deadline matters.
Item One: Is William Villeneuve the Next Man Up on Defence?
It’s been a patch-and-pray season on the blue line, and every time the Maple Leafs look stable, another injury hits. That’s why William Villeneuve’s steady climb with the American Hockey League (AHL) Toronto Marlies is suddenly worth paying attention to. He’s only 23, but after four AHL seasons and more than 200 games, he’s no longer the wide-eyed prospect from the Saint John Sea Dogs in the Quebec Maritimes Junior Hockey League (QMJHL). He’s now one of the Marlies’ anchors.
William Villeneuve, Toronto Marlies (Jonathan Kozub / Manitoba Moose)
His production has been consistent—25, 25, and 40 points in his first three years—and he’s on pace again this season, leading all Marlies defencemen. More importantly, he’s become a mentor for younger players like Noah Chadwick and Blake Smith as they settle in. The Marlies need him as they push for the playoffs, but so do the Maple Leafs, who may soon be short on bodies if injuries and deadline moves collide.
Related: Maple Leafs News & Rumours: Nylander, OEL, Raddysh & Rielly
Villeneuve isn’t a flashy call-up candidate, but he’s earned the right to be first in line when Toronto needs someone. And that time might be coming soon.
Item Two: Could Dougie Hamilton Really Be Toronto-Bound?
The Dougie Hamilton rumour refuses to die, mostly because it makes sense on paper. James Mirtle went as far as predicting Hamilton lands in Toronto, arguing the Maple Leafs need more playmaking on the back end—especially with Chris Tanev out and Morgan Rielly having an uneven season.
New Jersey Devils defenceman Dougie Hamilton defends against Vancouver Canucks forward Filip Chytil (Bob Frid-Imagn Images)
Hamilton’s contract (a $9 million cap hit through 2027–28) is no small detail, and neither is his injury history. But if the New Jersey Devils decide they need the salary cap space, the cost to acquire him could fall into a range Toronto can afford. That’s the gamble: big cap hit, big risk, but also a real chance to reshape the top of the blue line.
Related: Maple Leafs Need to Think Carefully Before Gambling on RaddyshÂ
On the flip side, Hamilton could also end up back with the Carolina Hurricanes, where he’s already proven he can thrive. It’s a split decision from two plugged-in writers, but the fact that Toronto keeps showing up in these conversations tells you something. The Maple Leafs know they need a bold swing. Hamilton would definitely qualify.
Item Three: Why This Deadline Actually Matters
For all the chaos this season, the Maple Leafs can still point to one thing they consistently do well: draft. When they hang onto their picks, they usually find players—Matthew Knies (round two), Easton Cowan (late round one), Nikita Grebenkin (round five), and Fraser Minten (round two) are proof of that. The issue isn’t talent evaluation. It’s that the picks and prospects rarely stick around long enough to matter.
Matthew Knies, Toronto Maple Leafs (Kim Klement Neitzel-Imagn Images)
Recent trades with the Boston Bruins and Philadelphia Flyers cost Toronto Minten, Grebenkin, Vashek Blanar, and three draft picks. Five future pieces gone, and the deals didn’t meaningfully change the team’s trajectory. That’s the frustrating part: the Maple Leafs draft well, then move those prospects before they have time to grow with the team.
Related: Maple Leafs News & Rumours: Matthews, Groulx, OEL & Roy Trades
That’s why this deadline should be about restocking. Toronto has only three picks in this year’s draft, which would tie the smallest draft class in franchise history. If they sell, adding two or three mid-round selections would help rebuild a pipeline that’s been thinned out by years of short-term swings.
What’s Next for the Maple Leafs?
Between the injuries, the deadline noise, and the uncertain direction of the season, Toronto is juggling a lot at once. But the next few weeks will offer clarity. If they chase help, Villeneuve might get pushed into NHL action sooner than expected. If they sell, the organization finally gets a chance to rebuild its draft capital. And if they stand somewhere in between—well, that might say even more about where they think this team is headed.
Either way, the decisions coming up won’t just shape the rest of the season. They’re going to influence the next few years of Maple Leafs hockey.
