Maple Leafs captain Auston Matthews faces ‘tough summer’ after knee surgery

The Toronto Maple Leafs will face a defining offseason after captain Auston Matthews underwent knee surgery that ended his 2025–26 NHL campaign.

The procedure, completed in New York on March 19, repaired a Grade 3 MCL tear in Matthews’ left knee. The injury adds another setback in a season where both player and team struggled to meet expectations.

Matthews picked up the injury during a collision with Radko Gudas, which later led to a 5 game suspension. He finished the season with 27 goals and 53 points in 60 games. Those numbers fall short of his usual standard, reflecting both injury disruption and the team’s wider inconsistency.

MORE: Former NHL HC Peter DeBoer explains what it’s like coaching Maple Leafs

During a Sportsnet broadcast, analysts shared mixed but realistic views on Matthews’ road ahead. Justin Bourne stressed the value of clarity after surgery, noting the decision removes uncertainty.

“This is just okay,” Bourne said. “They took care of it, they cleaned it up, shouldn’t be an issue for next year, and that’s what Leafs fans are looking for, that this guy’s going to have a full summer to get healthy, to train, and hopefully be at his best next year.”

Bourne believes a full offseason gives Matthews a strong chance to return at the peak level next year.

Nick Kypreos on Auston Matthews

Nick Kypreos offered a more personal perspective. Drawing from his own injury history, he described rehab as mentally draining and isolating. He called this offseason a turning point, where Matthews must rebuild both physically and mentally.

“A tough summer too, because we know what rehab does,” Kypreos said. “I’ve been through it. I blew up my ACL, my MCL, my meniscus. It can be lonely at times. There are a lot of times where you just are in your own inner thoughts.

“And let’s face it, this is a fork in the road for him. He’s coming off a couple of disappointing seasons, and this will have to be the summer where he gets himself not only physically ready, but mentally – for the challenge. Albeit we don’t know what the summer is going to look like for a lot of these guys, but he’s got a lot to prove coming back September.”

The recovery timeline sits around 12 weeks, with a return to skating expected in June. The organization remains confident he will be ready for training camp. Still, the pressure remains high after two underwhelming seasons.

Maple Leafs on the brink of elimination

Toronto’s struggles underline the importance of his comeback. The Leafs sit near the bottom of the Atlantic Division with a 29-28-13 record, and are close to missing the playoffs. They are not mathematically eliminated yet.

So, there are expectations attached as Matthews enters a critical summer. His recovery could shape not only his own future but also the direction of the franchise heading into 2026–27.

— Enjoy free coverage of the top news & trending stories on The Big Lead —

MARCH MADNESS: Predicting March Madness upsets in the 2026 NCAA Tournament

NFL DRAFT: New Mel Kiper NFL mock draft shows major impact of free agency

MLB: Dodgers announce Shohei Ohtani’s spring training pitching debut

NHL: Oilers’ Leon Draisaitl out for regular season with lower-body injury

ENTERTAINMENT: Is ‘Bachelorette’ still airing amid Taylor Frankie Paul domestic dispute allegations?

VIRAL: Livvy Dunne shares ‘Baywatch’ training with BTS swimsuit, set photos