Tristan Jarry’s difficult start with the Edmonton Oilers in the 2026-27 NHL season has drawn another sharp assessment from Pittsburgh-based analyst Josh Yohe.
Yohe, who works for The Athletic, highlighted Jarry’s recent struggles while praising Penguins general manager Kyle Dubas for completing the December trade that sent Jarry to Edmonton.
“Jarry has started in 18 games as a member of the Oilers,” Yohe wrote on X. “He’s allowed 4 or more goals in 10 of his last 12 starts.”
MORE: NHL analyst under fire after blunt take on Connor McDavid’s future in Edmonton
Yohe then listed Jarry’s goals allowed across those 18 starts. The stretch included six games allowing five or more goals and one seven-goal night.
“That Dubas was able to trade him for heavy return remains astonishing,” Yohe added.
Jarry’s latest outing provided more ammunition for the criticism. He allowed six goals on 23 shots during Edmonton’s 6-5 overtime loss to the Vancouver Canucks.
The Oilers surrendered three straight third-period goals before mounting a dramatic comeback. Edmonton eventually forced overtime but conceded Paul Cotter’s winner.
Oilers’ Tristan Jarry trade continues to draw scrutiny
Edmonton, Alberta, CAN; Edmonton Oilers goaltender Tristan Jarry (35) gets ready at Rogers Place. Mandatory Credit: Perry Nelson-Imagn Images via Reuters Connect (Reuters)
Edmonton acquired Jarry from Pittsburgh on Dec. 12, 2025, in a deal involving Stuart Skinner, Brett Kulak and a 2029 second-round pick. The Oilers also received forward Samuel Poulin. Edmonton assumed the remainder of Jarry’s five-year contract, carrying a $5.375 million average annual value.
Jarry struggled after arriving in Edmonton last season. He posted a 3.86 goals-against average and .858 save percentage across 19 regular-season appearances, including 16 starts. He also dealt with a lower-body injury and eventually lost his starting role. His playoff involvement was limited to one start.
The Oilers hoped the offseason would provide Jarry with a reset. Instead, his season debut immediately raised questions about Edmonton’s goaltending situation.
The contrast was especially notable because Evan Bouchard delivered a historic performance. The defenseman scored three goals and added two assists against Vancouver. Vasily Podkolzin also scored twice, including the late equalizer that forced overtime. Those efforts helped Edmonton recover from a 5-2 deficit.
MORE: Oilers receive tough injury news ahead of 2026-27 NHL season
So, right now, goaltending remains a major variable for Edmonton. The Oilers also have Devon Levi available, creating competition behind Jarry.
Yohe’s comments reflect how the trade is being viewed from Pittsburgh. For Edmonton, the focus is on whether Jarry can provide greater consistency. The Oilers face Vancouver again Thursday, giving Jarry and the team an immediate opportunity to respond.
— Enjoy free coverage of the top news & trending stories with The Big Lead Newsletter —